ARBITRATION
Denial Of Compensation Under A Particular Head Under NH Act Can Be Arbitrated: Rajasthan High Court
The Rajasthan High Court has held that the expression “amount determined” under the National Highways Act includes even cases where compensation is completely denied under a particular head, allowing landowners to challenge such decisions before an arbitrator. Justice Sanjeet Purohit ruled, “The expression 'amount determined' cannot be confined to the narrower meaning of 'amount quantified.' Determination is a process whereby a claim is examined in light of the material available on record and...
Delhi High Court Denies Interim Relief To Buyer As Developer's Claims Fail In Arbitration
The Delhi High Court has refused interim protection to a purchaser seeking to restrain the creation of third-party rights and maintain status quo over the first floor of a Greater Kailash-I property, holding that the claim could not survive once the developer's claimed authority to create such rights stood rejected in arbitrationJustice Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar held that the buyer's claim was entirely derivative of the Collaboration Agreement executed between developer Aditya Bhutani and the...
Delhi High Court Refuses Interim Relief To Commercial Space Licensee Against Delhi Metro Rail Corporation
The Delhi High Court has refused interim relief to QC One Solutions Pvt. Ltd. against Delhi Metro Rail Corporation's termination of a licence agreement for commercial spaces at three metro stations. The court prima facie found that the company had repeatedly defaulted on payment of licence fees and electricity dues despite multiple opportunities to cure the breaches. Justice Vikas Mahajan, in an order passed on May 20, held that QC One Solutions had failed to establish a prima facie case for...
Extension Without Liquidated Damages Does Not Bar Damages Or Bank Guarantee Invocation: Delhi HC
The Delhi High Court on 25 May held that extension of time without levy of liquidated damages does not, by itself, prevent a party from later invoking contractual remedies, including liquidated damages and enforcement of an unconditional bank guarantee, where disputes relating to delay and termination require arbitral adjudication. A Bench of Justice Mini Pushkarna declined relief to Kalpataru Projects International Limited and refused to grant interim protection under Section 9 of the...
Delhi HC Sets Aside ₹55 Lakh Arbitral Award To Budhiraja Electricals, Rejects Clause 10CC-Based Damages
The Delhi High Court on 22 May set aside arbitral awards granting Rs. 38.96 lakh towards escalation and Rs. 16.23 lakh towards loss of profits to Budhiraja Electricals in its dispute with the Public Works Department, Government of NCT of Delhi. Justice Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar held that an arbitral tribunal cannot use Clause 10CC of the General Conditions of Contract as a substitute for proof of actual loss once it finds the clause inapplicable to the extended period, and reiterated that...
High Courts' Supervisory Jurisdiction In Arbitration Falls Within 'Razor-Thin Compass': Delhi High Court
The Delhi High Court has held that its power to interfere in arbitral proceedings is confined to a “razor-thin compass,” refusing to interfere with an arbitral tribunal's rejection of Sunil Walia's jurisdictional objections in a partnership dispute involving Jason Enterprises. Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav observed that judicial intervention in arbitral matters must remain exceptional. “At the outset, it may be observed that there is no absolute bar on the exercise of jurisdiction under...
J&K High Court Refers ₹34.88 Crore HRCC–ERA Dispute To Arbitration, Holds Non-Operational DRE No Bar
The Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court on 22 May held that the existence of a contractual pre-arbitration dispute resolution mechanism cannot defeat a party's right to invoke arbitration under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, where such mechanism has not been operationalised. A Single-Judge Bench of Justice Sanjay Dhar appointed former Chief Justice of the High Court, Justice Ali Mohammad Magrey, as sole arbitrator to adjudicate disputes between Hassan Roads...
After Supreme Court Coal Block Ruling, Rajasthan High Court Restores Awards In Favour Of Parsa Kente Collieries
The Rajasthan High Court has effectively restored arbitral awards in favour of Parsa Kente Collieries Ltd. in its dispute with Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Ltd. The dispute concerned reimbursement of additional costs incurred after the Supreme Court's cancellation of coal block allocations and the subsequent continuation of the mining arrangement.In 2014, the Supreme Court had quashing coal block allocations across India, holding them arbitrary and illegal.A Division Bench of Acting...
Arbitration Clause In Tax Invoice Binding If Goods Accepted Without Protest: Allahabad High Court
The Allahabad High Court on 6 May held that an arbitration clause contained in the terms and conditions of a tax invoice constitutes a valid arbitration agreement when the receiving party accepts the goods supplied under the invoice without objection. Justice Piyush Agrawal appointed former judge Justice Vivek Kumar Birla as the sole arbitrator in a dispute between Ganesha Ecosphere Limited and Goodcore Spintex Pvt. Limited after holding that the parties were bound by the arbitration clause...
Delhi High Court Quashes ₹2.30 Crore Arbitral Award Against IRCTC In Meal Tariff Dispute
The Delhi High Court has set aside an arbitral award directing Indian Railway Catering and Tourism Corporation Ltd. (IRCTC) to pay ₹2.30 crore to Foodworld in a dispute over reimbursement for second regular meals and welcome drinks under railway catering contracts. Justice Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar held that the controversy was substantially covered by the Supreme Court's ruling in Indian Railways Catering and Tourism Corp. Ltd. v. Brandavan Food Products. “The interpretation adopted by the...
Patna HC Sets Aside ₹25 Lakh Arbitral Compensation Against Bihar State Food Corporation For No Proof of Loss
The Patna High Court has partly set aside an arbitral award against Bihar State Food and Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd, holding that compensation awarded without evidence of actual loss or injury could not be sustained. A Division Bench of Justice Mohit Kumar Shah and Justice Arun Kumar Jha held: “Thus, there is no proof much less any evidence whatsoever, on the records of the arbitral proceedings regarding the claimant-respondent having suffered any loss or injury, hence the award of...
LiveLawBiz Arbitration Cases Weekly Digest: May 18 - May 23, 2026
NOMINAL INDEXPatanjali Ayurved Limited and Ors. Versus Ashav Advisory LLP, 2026 LLBiz SC 196Pandrol Rahee Technologies Pvt. Ltd. v. IRCON International Ltd., 2026 LLBiz HC(DEL) 518Cinda Engineering and Construction Private Limited v. CY Engineering India Private Limited, 2026 LLBiz HC(DEL) 506Sarvesh Security Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Institute of Human Behavior Resource and Allied Sciences, 2026 LLBiz HC(DEL) 516Dewan and Sons and Ors. Vs Harsh International, 2026 LLBiz HC(DEL) 526Hazel Mercantile...