NCLT Mumbai Dismisses Insolvency Plea Against JAS Toll Road Over Collusion, Imposes ₹2.5 Lakh Penalty

  • NCLT Mumbai Dismisses Insolvency Plea Against JAS Toll Road Over Collusion, Imposes ₹2.5 Lakh Penalty

    The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Mumbai Bench, has dismissed an insolvency petition filed by Apkon Ventures Private Limited against JAS Toll Road Company Limited, holding that the proceedings were initiated to frustrate restitution and contempt proceedings before the Delhi High Court.

    The bench of Judicial Member Vinay Goel and Technical Member Charanjeet Singh Gulati found that the petition was part of a collusive arrangement between the two companies and was not intended to resolve insolvency.

    “...the Section 9 petition was filed, kept alive through a settlement and withdrawal, and revived by a collusive arrangement between Respondent No. 1 and Respondent No. 2, not for resolution of insolvency but to frustrate the restitution and contempt proceedings pending before the Hon'ble Delhi High Court,” the tribunal held.

    Apkon had filed the petition under Section 9 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), claiming ₹1.06 crore with interest at 12% per annum. The claim arose from overlay work carried out on the Nelamangala-Tumkur section of NH-4 under a contract dated March 1, 2019.

    The National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) had alleged that the insolvency proceedings were collusive and intended to frustrate its restitution proceedings against JAS Toll Road before the Delhi High Court.

    The tribunal rejected Apkon's objection that NHAI, as a third party, could not raise such an objection before admission of the insolvency petition. It held that an application under Section 65 of the IBC, which deals with fraudulent or malicious initiation of insolvency proceedings, can be considered once a Section 9 petition is filed. Admission of the petition is not necessary.

    The tribunal also examined the settlement between Apkon and JAS Toll Road. Under an agreement dated January 9, 2025, JAS Toll Road had agreed to pay ₹1.20 crore in six instalments. The petition was withdrawn on February 4, 2025, with liberty to seek its revival in case of default. It was later restored after the post-dated cheques issued under the settlement were dishonoured.

    The tribunal noted that JAS Toll Road had not disclosed the Independent Engineer's rejection of the overlay work or an arbitral award that found that the work had not been redone. It also did not specifically deny NHAI's allegations of collusion and non-disclosure.

    Holding that the petition had been initiated with malicious intent, the tribunal allowed NHAI's application and dismissed Apkon's insolvency petition. It imposed a penalty of ₹2.5 lakh on Apkon and JAS Toll Road, directing them to pay the amount to the Prime Minister's National Relief Fund within two weeks.

    For NHAI: Advocates Abhay Gupta, Arpit Sharma, and Anshuli

    For the Operational Creditor: Advocates Mahek Saudagar instructed by Yahya Batatawala

    For the Respondent in IVN.P/159/2025, IA/5339/2025: Advocates Yahya Batatawal, Mahek Saudagar

    For the Respondent in IVN.P/159/2025: Advocates Omkar Deosthale along with Nisha Kaba, Abhijit Singh (R2)

    Case Title :  Apkon Ventures Private Limited v. JAS Toll Road Company LimitedCase Number :  C.P. (IB) No. 638/MB/2024, along with I.A. (IBC) No. 5339/2025 and IVN.P. (IBC) No. 159/2025CITATION :  2026 LLBiz NCLT (MUM) 1133
    Next Story