Landowner With Consent Rights Over Developer's Key Business Decisions Is Related Party Under IBC: NCLT Mumbai

  • Landowner With Consent Rights Over Developers Key Business Decisions Is Related Party Under IBC: NCLT Mumbai

    The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) at Mumbai on Thursday held that a landowner's contractual rights to consent to specified decisions concerning a real estate developer's principal business can make it a related party under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC).

    The Bench of Judicial Member Nilesh Sharma and Technical Member Charanjeet Singh Gulati observed:

    “The definition of 'related party' under Section 5(24) is exhaustive. The provision in Section 5(24)(m)(i) of the Code specifically provides that a person may be considered a related party of the Corporate Debtor if the person is associated with it on account of participation in its policy-making processes. Under clause (i), the relevant consideration is whether the person participates in decisions shaping the Corporate Debtor's policies or business direction, rather than merely having a contractual or commercial relationship with it.”

    Pune Kondhwa Realty and Lake District Realty, the corporate debtor, entered into a Joint Development Agreement (JDA) on June 27, 2016, for developing 67,272 sq. m. of land at Yeolewadi, Pune.

    Pune Kondhwa Realty extended deposits to Lake District Realty from 2017 to support the development. An amount of ₹42.46 crore remained outstanding.

    After insolvency proceedings began on November 2, 2023, Pune Kondhwa Realty filed a financial creditor claim of ₹42.46 crore, which the RP admitted. However, the RP excluded it from the CoC, classifying it as a related party.

    Pune Kondhwa Realty challenged the decision, arguing that the JDA was an arm's-length arrangement that gave it no control over the corporate debtor.

    The tribunal noted that the JDA required the landowner's consent for specified project decisions, changes to construction-finance disbursements and certain bank transactions. It also noted that the project was Lake District Realty's sole revenue-generating asset.

    Relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in Phoenix ARC Pvt. Ltd. v. Spade Financial Services Ltd., the tribunal held that the landowner's contractual rights gave it a role in decisions shaping the corporate debtor's business direction. It upheld the related-party classification, barring the landowner from participating or voting in the CoC.

    The tribunal clarified that this would not affect admission of its claim and left the validity and effect of the JDA termination to separate proceedings.

    For Applicant: Advocate Rohit Gupta, along with Advocates Mansi and Abhishek Rajan.

    For Respondent: Advocate Yahya Batatawala

    Case Title :  Pune Kondhwa Realty Private Limited v. Kedar Mulye (Resolution Professional of Lake District Realty Private Limited)Case Number :  IA (IBC) No. 5674/2025 in CP (IB) No. 787/2021CITATION :  2026 LLBiz NCLT (MUM) 1147
    Next Story