Service Of Demand Notice At Correct Address Mandatory For Insolvency Proceedings: NCLT Ahmedabad

  • Service Of Demand Notice At Correct Address Mandatory For Insolvency Proceedings: NCLT Ahmedabad

    Proper service of a demand notice at the Corporate Debtor's correct address is mandatory for initiating insolvency proceedings under Section 9 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC), the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Ahmedabad Bench, has ruled.

    The tribunal made the observation while rejecting an insolvency petition filed by U.P. Analab against Surya Hybrid (India) Private Limited over alleged unpaid dues of ₹1.27 crore.

    A Bench of Judicial Member Chitra Hankare and Technical Member Dr. V. G. Venkata Chalapathy ruled,

    “If the goods delivered have not been paid the applicant has to resort to alternate course of law for recovery than IBC 2016, which has to comply with proper serving of notice at the correct address. Serving notice at correct address under Section 8 is mandatory requirement.”

    U.P. Analab, a sole proprietorship dealing in silver ornaments and bullion, alleged that Surya Hybrid had purchased silver ornaments and bullion from it in 2021 but failed to pay for the supplies.

    It claimed that three invoices raised in July 2022, amounting to ₹1.27 crore, remained unpaid despite repeated reminders and assurances from the Corporate Debtor's representatives.

    It sent a demand notice under Section 8 of the IBC on November 19, 2024. However, the notice sent by speed post was returned with the endorsement "no such person found".

    The creditor later emailed the notice to the Corporate Debtor's registered email address, but received no response.

    The insolvency court had initially dismissed the insolvency petition in July 2025. The NCLAT later remanded the matter, allowing the creditor another opportunity to establish its case.

    Following the remand, U.P. Analab produced GST records to support the genuineness of the transactions. It also argued that silver items were exempt from e-way bill requirements.

    The tribunal, however, found that the creditor had not established proper service of the demand notice. It also found its explanation of the business relationship with the Corporate Debtor unclear. Emails and WhatsApp conversations were insufficient to justify admitting the petition.

    Observing that the IBC could not be used as a recovery mechanism, the tribunal directed the creditor to pursue other legal remedies and dismissed the petition.

    For Applicants: Advocate Pranjal M. Buch

    Case Title :  U.P. Analab Vs Surya Hybrid (India) Pvt LtdCase Number :  C.P.(IB)/288(AHM)2025CITATION :  2026LLBiz NCLT (AHM) 1143
    Next Story