NCLT Ahmedabad Allows German Oldenburgische Landesbank AG's Full Claim Despite Indemnification
Sandhra Suresh
21 Nov 2026 3:48 PM IST

The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Ahmedabad, on 18 November allowed an application filed by Oldenburgische Landesbank AG, setting aside the Resolution Professional's (RP) decision to partially reject the bank's claim in the CIRP of Sumeet Industries Limited.
A Bench comprising Judicial Member Chitra Hankare and Technical Member Dr. VG Venkata Chalapathy held that indemnification received by a financial creditor under Germany's Buyer Credit Guarantee Scheme cannot, by itself, justify reducing its claim against a corporate debtor during the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP). It observed:
“The question of filing the claim before the RP thereby is to be allowed irrespective of whether the Federal German Agency has to file or limitation period as the claim has been partially allowed by the RP. Hence this application is liable to be allowed.”
Oldenburgische Landesbank AG, a German banking institution, had extended a buyer's credit facility of up to EUR 10,444,450 to Sumeet Industries under a credit agreement executed in 2011.
The bank disbursed the facility in several tranches between September 2011 and May 2012. However, Sumeet Industries defaulted on its repayment obligations from February 2015. Following continued defaults, the bank issued demand notices and terminated the credit agreement in April 2019, demanding repayment of the entire outstanding amount.
After CIRP commenced against Sumeet Industries in December 2022, the bank submitted a claim of approximately EUR 8,284,427.15. However, the RP admitted only a portion of the claim, amounting to approximately Rs. 11.14 crore.
The RP rejected the remaining amount on the ground that the bank had already received substantial indemnification under the Export Guarantee Insurance Scheme backed by the Federal Republic of Germany before the commencement of CIRP.
Aggrieved by the partial rejection, the bank approached the Tribunal under Section 60(5) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.
The bank contended that the indemnification received under the Buyer Credit Guarantee Scheme did not extinguish Sumeet Industries' liability. It submitted that the guarantee arrangement was a confidential German instrument intended to facilitate international trade and protect German lenders.
It further submitted that any subsequent recoveries from Sumeet Industries would be remitted to the Federal Republic of Germany, except for the uninsured portion. Therefore, recognising the full claim would not result in double enrichment.
The RP and Bank of Baroda, on the other hand, argued that payment of indemnification transferred the relevant rights to the German Government under the principle of subrogation. They submitted that the bank could initiate legal proceedings only on behalf of the Federal Government.
They also argued that the approved resolution plan had attained finality and that claims not forming part of the plan or not admitted in full stood extinguished. Further, they contended that admitting the entire claim at this stage would adversely affect the voting rights and distribution of amounts among other creditors.
The Tribunal accepted the bank's submissions and noted that the relevant documents expressly authorised it to continue enforcing its claims against Sumeet Industries notwithstanding the indemnification received from the German Government. It also observed that the guarantee mechanism functioned as a trade-support arrangement.
It also noted that any recoveries obtained by the bank would ultimately flow to the Federal Republic of Germany.
Further, the Bench observed that expecting the German Government or its agencies to independently file claims before the RP would be impractical when the bank had been specifically authorised to exercise and administer the subrogated rights.
Accordingly, the NCLT set aside the RP's decision partially rejecting the bank's claim and directed the monitoring committee to recognise its full claim.
For Applicants: Senior Advocate Megha Jani with Advocates Siddharth Sinha, Bijal Chhatrapati, Varghese Thomas, Fatema Kachwalla, Arvind Parikh, & Dishay Chitalia
For Respondents: Advocate Anmol Vyas, Abhishek Purohit, and Bajrang Singh for R1; Advocate Jaimin Dave for R2
