NCLT Ahmedabad Admits Shri Niwas Leasing's Insolvency Plea Against Tiaan Consumer

  • NCLT Ahmedabad Admits Shri Niwas Leasings Insolvency Plea Against Tiaan Consumer

    On 17 November, the Ahmedabad Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) admitted an insolvency petition filed by Shri Niwas Leasing and Finance Limited proceedings against Tiaan Consumer Limited over a default of Rs. 106.61 crore.

    A Bench of Judicial Member Shammi Khan and Technical Member Sanjeev Sharma held that execution of a loan agreement after disbursement does not, by itself, negate the existence of a financial debt under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC). It observed:

    “The execution of the Loan Agreement subsequent to disbursement, by itself, does not negate the existence of financial debt, particularly when the subsequent Supplementary Loan Agreement dated 05.08.2025 records the outstanding principal liability of Rs.90.00 Crore along with applicable interest. The transaction is required to be examined in the light of Section 5(8) of the Code, including the consideration for time value of money.”

    The Financial Creditor submitted that it had disbursed an aggregate sum of Rs. 90 crore to Tiaan Consumer in December 2024. Subsequently, the parties executed a Loan Agreement on 11 January 2025, providing for repayment with interest at 12% per annum.

    At the request of Tiaan Consumer, the parties extended the repayment period through a Supplementary Loan Agreement dated 5 August 2025. The agreement extended the loan tenure to 20 months from the date of first disbursement and recorded Tiaan Consumer's acknowledgement of the outstanding liability.

    The Financial Creditor contended that the extended repayment tenure expired on 11 August 2026, but Tiaan Consumer failed to repay the loan. It relied on the loan documents and ledger reconciliation statements to establish the outstanding liability. It further submitted that the loan recall notice issued on 4 September 2026 was merely a formal demand issued after the default had occurred.

    Opposing the petition, Tiaan Consumer argued that the application was premature and not maintainable. It contended that the Financial Creditor had failed to establish an enforceable financial debt or clearly identify the date of default.

    It further argued that the Financial Creditor could not rely on the expiry of the extended repayment tenure as the date of default while also issuing a subsequent recall notice. It disputed the interest computation and questioned whether the transaction qualified as a financial debt under the IBC, particularly since the Loan Agreement was executed after disbursement.

    The Tribunal held that the post-disbursement execution of the Loan Agreement did not negate the existence of a financial debt, particularly when the Supplementary Loan Agreement acknowledged the outstanding principal of Rs. 90 crore along with interest.

    It rejected Tiaan Consumer's objections concerning interest calculations, TDS certificates and account reconciliation. It held that these objections could not displace the documentary acknowledgement of the principal liability.

    Further, the Bench found that the parties had contractually extended the repayment tenure until 11 August 2026 and that the subsequent loan recall notice did not alter the agreed maturity date. It also held that settlement discussions after default did not affect the existence of the financial debt.

    Accordingly, the NCLT admitted the petition, initiated the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) against Tiaan Consumer, appointed Mukesh Kumar Jain as the Interim Resolution Professional and imposed the statutory moratorium.

    For Applicants: Advocate Aadarsh Rai

    For Respondents: Advocate Jainish Shah

    Case Title :  Shri Niwas Leasing and Finance Limited Vs Tiaan Consumer LimitedCase Number :  C.P.(IB)/289(AHM)2026CITATION :  2026LLBiz NCLT (AHM) 1140
    Next Story