Gujarat High Court Holds Company Entitled To Interest On ₹2.50 Crore TDS Refund

The Gujarat High Court has ruled that Maharashtra Border Check Post Network Ltd. is entitled to interest on a ₹2.50 crore refund arising from a TDS demand that was later set aside. The court held that the company's claim was covered by Section 244A(1)(b) of the Income Tax Act and could not be denied by relying on Section 244A(1B), which came into effect from April 1, 2017.A Division Bench of Justice A.S. Supehia and Justice Vaibhavi D. Nanavati observed that Section 244A(1)(b) already provided...

Diary Entries At Partner's Premises Insufficient For Additions Without Link To Firm: Gujarat High Court

The Gujarat High Court on 8 September held that diary entries or other material found during survey proceedings cannot, by themselves, justify additions in the hands of a partnership firm when the material was not recovered from the firm's premises and there is no independent evidence linking the transactions recorded in it to the firm. A Bench of Justices Bhargav D. Karia and Pranav Trivedi dismissed the Revenue's appeals against Expert Particle Board and its partner, upholding the orders of...

Gujarat High Court Upholds Tax Disallowance To J.K. Paper On Expenses For Supervising Farmer-Grown Trees

The Gujarat High Court has upheld an Income Tax Appellate Tribunal finding that expenditure incurred by J K Paper Limited on supervising trees grown by farmers could not be treated as agricultural expenditure. The tribunal had also excluded expenditure on producing coppice shoots through a process that did not involve primary operations on land.A bench of Justice Bhargav D. Karia and Justice Pranav Trivedi upheld the tribunal's decision to restrict the disallowance of agricultural loss to ₹9.43...

Gujarat High Court Quashes GST Demand, Holds ITC Cannot Be Denied On Non-Taxable Transaction

The Gujarat High Court has held that tax authorities cannot deny input tax credit on a transaction that was not taxable in the first place.A bench of Justice A.S. Supehia and Justice Vaibhavi D. Nanavati made the ruling while quashing a GST demand against Kor Chems over credit claimed on the acquisition of leasehold rights in a GIDC industrial plot. The court held that the ITC reversal and interest could not survive after finding that GST was not leviable on the transfer of the leasehold...

Gujarat High Court Sets Aside Polymech's ₹40.53 Lakh Majority Award, Upholds ₹4.25 Lakh Minority Award

The Gujarat High Court set aside majority awards granting Rs. 40.53 lakh to Polymech Plast Machines Limited in its insurance dispute with National Insurance Company Limited and upheld the minority award granting Rs. 4.25 lakh. A Division Bench comprising Chief Justice Sunita Agarwal and Justice D.N. Ray held that an arbitral award is vitiated by perversity where arbitrators rely on an office note as the governing insurance policy while excluding the policy containing the arbitration clause. The...

Gujarat High Court Admits Ford India Plea Against GST Demands Based On E-Way Bill Discrepancies

The Gujarat High Court on 3 September admitted connected writ petitions filed by Ford India Private Limited challenging show-cause notices and Orders-in-Original issued under Section 74 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, concerning alleged discrepancies between taxable values and e-way bill data. A Division Bench of Justices A.S. Supehia and Vaibhavi D. Nanavati found that the adjudicating authority had expressed its inability to reconcile the voluminous data despite the material...

Gujarat High Court Quashes GST Demand Against Environmental Entity, Holds Effluent Treatment Exempt

The Gujarat High Court has held that an environmental protection entity qualified for a nil GST rate on activities falling within charitable activities involving preservation of the environment. The court also found no deliberate intention to evade tax and quashed the show-cause notice issued by the GST authorities.A Division Bench of Justice A.S. Supehia and Justice Vaibhavi D. Nanavati allowed the petition filed by Naroda Enviro Projects Ltd. and its co-petitioner. The dispute concerned GST...

SEZ Units Cannot Be Denied Stamp Duty Exemption Due To Pre-Ordinance Lease: Gujarat High Court

The Gujarat High Court on 2 September held that an SEZ unit cannot be denied exemption from stamp duty and registration fee merely because its lease deed was executed before the Gujarat Special Economic Zone Ordinance, 2004 came into force, where the investment was made on the basis of the State Government's earlier SEZ policy promising such fiscal incentives. A Division Bench comprising Chief Justice Sunita Agarwal and Justice D.N. Ray dismissed the State Government's appeal against an order...

GST Appeal Limitation To Run From Rectification Order Where Application Filed In Time: Gujarat High Court

The Gujarat High Court has ruled that a GST appeal cannot be rejected as time-barred by calculating limitation solely from the original adjudication order when the assessee had filed a rectification application within the prescribed period and the application was subsequently decided by the adjudicating authority.A Division Bench comprising Justice A.S. Supehia and Justice Vaibhavi D. Nanavati observed, “It would not be permissible to reject the appeal on the ground of limitation by computing...

Gujarat High Court Dismisses Revenue's ₹3.44 Cr Service Tax Appeal Over Fees Collected From Gir Forest Visitors

The Gujarat High Court has dismissed a Revenue appeal against the Deputy Conservator of Forests in a ₹3.44-crore service tax dispute over permit fees, entry fees, camera fees, and other charges collected from visitors to Gir Forest.The court relied on an earlier ruling that had held that such fees cannot be treated as consideration for taxable services, as the Deputy Conservator of Forests was discharging sovereign functions while collecting them in his official capacity.A Division Bench...

Sale Of Counterfeit Apple Accessories Cannot Be Prosecuted As Copyright Offence: Gujarat High Court Quashes FIR

The Gujarat High Court on Monday quashed a copyright infringement FIR against a shopkeeper accused of selling counterfeit Apple accessories, ruling that the allegations essentially concerned trademark misuse rather than copyright infringement.Justice P.M. Raval observed that the FIR and seizure memo did not identify any specific literary or artistic work allegedly copied from Apple. “The dispute essentially pertains to the alleged falsification of a registered trademark on commercial...

Gujarat High Court Quashes DVO Reference Made A Day Before Assessment Became Time-Barred

The Gujarat High Court has quashed an Assessing Officer's reference to the Departmental Valuation Officer (DVO) made just a day before the assessment was due to become time-barred. The court held that the reference was a colourable exercise aimed at extending the time available to complete the assessment.A bench comprising Justice A.S. Supehia and Justice Vaibhavi D. Nanavati found that the material relating to the company's assets and payments was already available with the Assessing Officer....