CESTAT Chennai Allows CENVAT Credit On Factory Land Lease Despite Omission Of 'Setting Up' From Rules

  • CESTAT Chennai Allows CENVAT Credit On Factory Land Lease Despite Omission Of Setting Up From Rules

    The Chennai Bench of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) on 4 November held that service tax paid on a long-term lease of land for establishing a factory qualifies for CENVAT credit as an input service under Rule 2(l) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, despite the omission of the words “setting up” from the provision in 2011.

    A Bench comprising Judicial Member Ajayan T.V. and Technical Member Vasa Seshagiri Rao, while allowing an appeal filed by Heat and Control (South Asia) Private Limited, also held that availing credit under a different service tax registration of the same legal entity is a curable procedural irregularity, and set aside the demand of Rs. 2,31,65,730, along with interest and penalty. It said:

    “..The exclusions follow that, and clause (A) excludes construction and works contract services in so far as they are used for construction of a building or civil structure or for laying foundations. Renting of immovable property is not among the excluded services. The amendment of 2011 narrowed the inclusive part. It left the main part untouched and added no exclusion for setting up”.

    The dispute arose after the appellant obtained 8.33 acres of land at Mahindra World City, Chengalpattu, under a 99-year lease to establish a manufacturing facility. It paid a non-refundable premium of Rs. 18.74 crore, on which service tax and applicable cesses of Rs. 2,31,65,730 were charged.

    The appellant availed the credit under its Anna Nagar service tax registration in July 2014. The Department denied the credit, contending that the words “setting up” had been omitted from Rule 2(l) with effect from 1 April 2011 and that the leased land had no nexus with the services provided from the Anna Nagar office.

    The Principal Commissioner of GST and Central Excise, Chennai North, confirmed recovery of the credit along with interest and imposed an equivalent penalty under Rule 15(3) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, read with Section 78 of the Finance Act, 1994.

    The Tribunal observed that although the 2011 amendment omitted “setting up” from the inclusive part of Rule 2(l), the main definition remained unchanged. It held that leasing land for establishing a factory has a direct nexus with manufacturing, since no factory or manufacturing activity can exist without land.

    It also noted that renting of immovable property was not covered by the exclusion clause. The subsequent commencement of manufacturing did not affect credit eligibility, as Rule 4(7) does not require commercial production to have commenced before credit can be availed.

    On the issue of the different service tax registration, the Bench held that entitlement to credit flows from the status of the legal entity under Rule 3(1), rather than merely from the registration in which the credit is recorded. It also found from the ST-3 returns that the lease-related credit remained unutilised until its reversal. It observed:

    “..the service tax on the lease premium was paid on an input service of the appellant as a manufacturer, and the omission of “setting up” from the inclusive part of Rule 2(l) does not exclude it. The credit was taken in the account of another registration of the same person, which was a procedural irregularity...”

    Further, the Tribunal held that interest was not payable on admissible credit and that the penalty was unsustainable in the absence of deliberate suppression or wilful misstatement. It criticised the adjudicating authority for alleging misstatement regarding utilisation without examining the Department's own records.

    Accordingly, the CESTAT allowed the appeal and set aside the demand, interest and penalty.

    For Appellant: Ms. Disha Jain, Advocate

    For Respondent: Mr. M. Selvakumar, Authorised Representative

    Case Title :  Heat and Control (South Asia) Private Limited v. Principal Commissioner of GST & Central ExciseCase Number :  Excise Appeal No.41410 of 2018CITATION :  2026 LLBiz CESTAT(CHE) 661
    Next Story