CESTAT Chandigarh Grants ₹1.19 Crore CENVAT Credit Relief To Maruti Suzuki In Natural Gas Procurement Dispute

  • CESTAT Chandigarh Grants ₹1.19 Crore CENVAT Credit Relief To Maruti Suzuki In Natural Gas Procurement Dispute

    The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Chandigarh on Thursday has allowed Maruti Suzuki India Limited to claim CENVAT credit of ₹1,19,81,989 (about ₹1.20 crore) on service tax paid by GAIL on compensation received for short-offtake of natural gas.

    The tribunal held that the compensation was connected with the procurement of natural gas, which Maruti Suzuki used as an input in manufacturing motor vehicles.

    A bench of Judicial Member P. Dinesha and Technical Member P. Anjani Kumar held that the payment qualified as an input service under the inclusive part of Rule 2(l) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.

    The tribunal observed, “The penal amount paid by the appellants to GAIL is undoubtedly in relation to the procurement of goods. If the appellants did not procure natural gas from GAIL, there would have been no occasion to pay the penal amount and the applicable service tax for the same.”

    Maruti Suzuki had entered into an agreement with the Gas Authority of India Limited (GAIL) to procure natural gas for manufacturing motor vehicles. Under the agreement, it was required to purchase a minimum quantity of gas every month, failing which it had to pay a penalty.

    The company fell short of the minimum off-take requirement for around four to five years. Following a mutual understanding with GAIL, it paid ₹8.56 crore as compensation for the short offtake. GAIL discharged service tax on this amount, treating it as consideration for the declared service of tolerating an act or a situation.

    Maruti Suzuki subsequently availed CENVAT credit of ₹1,19,81,989 on the service tax paid by GAIL. The Revenue disputed the credit, arguing that the company had not received any input service against the payment.

    A show cause notice issued on December 7, 2016, led to confirmation of the demand and imposition of penalty. The Commissioner (Appeals), Central GST, Gurugram, upheld the order, following which Maruti Suzuki approached the tribunal.

    Appearing for the company, counsel Krati Singh, assisted by Samiksha Uniyal, argued that CENVAT credit could not be denied at the recipient's end when the service tax paid by the provider had not been disputed. They relied on CBEC circulars and judicial precedents, including Sarvesh Refractories, Royal Sundaram General Insurance Company and Modular Auto.

    The company also pointed out that its Manesar unit had a similar arrangement with GAIL and had availed similar credit without facing any proceedings.

    Opposing the appeal, the Revenue submitted that it was not disputing the service tax paid by GAIL. Its objection was that the service did not qualify as an input service for Maruti Suzuki under Rule 2(l).

    The tribunal noted that the inclusive part of the definition of 'input service' permits credit on services used in relation to the procurement of inputs.

    It found that the compensation arose directly from Maruti Suzuki's procurement arrangement with GAIL. The company would not have had to pay the compensation or the applicable service tax had it not procured natural gas from GAIL.

    The tribunal also observed that the Revenue had not disputed the service tax paid by GAIL. Having accepted that GAIL had rendered a service, it could not contend that Maruti Suzuki had not received any service.

    Setting aside the impugned order, the tribunal allowed the appeal with consequential relief.

    For Appellant: Krati Singh and Samiksha Uniyal

    For Respondent: Aniram Meena and G.D. Bansal

    Case Title :  Maruti Suzuki India Limited v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Goods & Service Tax, GurugramCase Number :  Excise Appeal No. 61399 of 2019CITATION :  2026 LLBiz CESTAT(CHA) 667
    Next Story