NCLT Mumbai Criticises 'Copy & Paste' Pleadings, Imposes ₹5 Lakh Costs While Restoring Praddum Trading
Mohd.Rehan Ali
16 Nov 2026 4:40 PM IST

The Mumbai Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), on 4 November criticised the practice of filing casually drafted pleadings containing incorrect and unsupported averments, observing that reliance on “copy & paste” material wastes valuable judicial time.
A Bench of Judicial Member Lakshmi Gurung and Technical Member Hariharan Neelakanta Iyer made the observations while allowing a petition filed by Praddum Trading Company Private Limited under Section 252 of the Companies Act, 2013, seeking restoration of its name to the Register of Companies. It stated:
“…A wrong or incorrect citation of a section or sub-section in the pleading will not be fatal in outcome of the petition and may be accommodated, as the technicality is mere handmaid to substantial justice. However, what worries this Tribunal is that in the path of discovery of truth, much judicial time is consumed. If the counsel/professionals would take serious efforts in proper drafting to focus on correct and true averments in a particular case without any copy & paste material (available on shelf), then it would be a great service to the judiciary by saving valuable judicial time.”
The company had approached the NCLT after the Registrar of Companies (RoC), Mumbai, struck off its name in 2018.
In its initial pleadings, the company claimed that it was operational at the time of the strike-off and was in the process of completing and filing its income tax returns. It also claimed to have prepared its financial statements and annual returns.
However, when the Tribunal sought details of the company's business activities, its counsel candidly admitted that the company was not carrying on any business at the time of the strike-off. The company instead sought restoration under Section 252(3), contending that it held valuable investments in other companies and that restoration was necessary to protect those assets.
The Bench noted that the company had made incorrect and unsupported averments in its pleadings. It observed that the admission regarding the company's inactivity came only after the Bench sought further clarification during the proceedings.
It emphasised that counsel and professionals must make serious efforts to ensure that pleadings contain correct and truthful averments instead of relying on readily available “copy & paste” material. It also clarified that an incorrect statutory provision cited in a pleading would not, by itself, be fatal to a petition, but careless drafting that necessitates repeated clarifications consumes valuable judicial time.
Thereafter, the Tribunal examined whether the company qualified for restoration under Section 252(3) of the Companies Act. It noted that the company held valuable movable or immovable property and that the RoC had raised no objection to the investment details placed on record by the company.
Therefore, it directed the RoC to restore the company's name to the Register of Companies and change its status from “Struck Off” to “Active”.
Considering the company's failure to file statutory documents and the judicial time consumed in obtaining repeated clarifications, the Bench made the restoration conditional upon payment of Rs. 5,00,000 as costs to the Pay and Accounts Officer, Ministry of Corporate Affairs.
Accordingly, the NCLT allowed the restoration petition subject to payment of costs of Rs. 5,00,000.
For Applicant: Adv. Prashant Thakre (PH)
For RoC: Mr. Shivraj C. Ranjeri, DRoC, Mumbai-1 (VC)
