Madras High Court Holds Seematti Silks Cannot Challenge Rival's 'SEEMATTI' Trademark After Acquiescence

  • Madras High Court Holds Seematti Silks Cannot Challenge Rivals SEEMATTI Trademark After Acquiescence

    The Madras High Court has dismissed a trademark rectification petition filed by Seematti Silks, seeking removal of a rival textile business owner's registration of the 'SEEMATTI' trademark.

    Justice K. Kumaresh Babu held that Seematti Silks could not challenge the registration after failing to take action despite knowing about the rival's predecessor's claim of prior use of the mark since 1994.

    The dispute concerned the registration of the 'SEEMATTI' trademark in favour of the rival textile business owner, who claimed that the mark had been in use since June 1, 1910. Seematti Silks contended that it had adopted the mark in 1986 and that the rival had falsely claimed use since 1910 to secure the registration.

    It argued that the rival had failed to substantiate its claimed date of use and had subsequently amended the date in another trademark application from June 1, 1910, to February 16, 1995, after the Trade Marks Registry asked it to establish the earlier date.

    Opposing the petition, the rival argued that its predecessors had established a textile store under the name 'SEEMATTI' in 1910 and had obtained trademark registrations as early as 1963. It also contended that Seematti Silks had known about its predecessor's claim since 1994 but had failed to challenge it.

    The court noted that the rival's predecessor had opposed Seematti Silks' trademark application in 1994, claiming that the 'SEEMATTI' mark had been used since 1932. Although the opposition was subsequently abandoned, the court held that it established Seematti Silks' knowledge of the predecessor's prior-use claim. It also noted that the predecessor had obtained trademark registrations as early as 1963.

    The court referred to Section 33 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, which protects a later registered trademark from challenge if the proprietor of an earlier trademark knowingly allows its use to continue for five years. This protection does not apply if the later trademark was applied for in bad faith.

    Finding that Seematti Silks had failed to establish that the rival's trademark was adopted in bad faith, the court held that Seematti Silks had acquiesced to the use of the mark and could no longer challenge its registration.

    Accordingly, the court dismissed the rectification petition, with no order as to costs.

    For Seematti Silks: Advocate Rajesh Ramanathan

    For Respondents: Advocate Ramesh Ganapathay for R1; SPCGSC A.R.Sakthivel for R2

    Case Title :  M/s. Seematti Silks v. Ms. T. Beena & The Registrar of TrademarksCase Number :  OP(TM) No. 529 of 2023CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (MAD) 360
    Next Story