Continuing Trade Mark Infringement Despite Delay Warrants Mediation Exemption: Calcutta High Court

  • Continuing Trade Mark Infringement Despite Delay Warrants Mediation Exemption: Calcutta High Court

    The Calcutta High Court on 13 November held that delay in filing a suit does not negate urgency where infringement of an intellectual property right is continuing. Such cases can qualify for exemption from pre-institution mediation under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015.

    A Bench comprising Justices Debangsu Basak and Ajay Kumar Gupta set aside an order refusing Malhotra International Private Limited exemption from mediation in its trade mark infringement suit over the mark “PANAMA”.

    Malhotra International said it had been selling shaving blades under the mark “PANAMA” since 1951 and held a registered trade mark for the word since 1954. It discovered the respondents' products bearing the mark in the second week of September 2026 and filed the suit on 9 October 2026. A rectification application filed by the respondents against its trade mark is pending before the Registrar.

    The respondents contended that they had been selling blades under “PANAMA” since 20 January 2026, that Malhotra International knew of their use, and that the delay justified the refusal to dispense with mediation.

    The Court noted that Section 12A makes pre-institution mediation mandatory, except where a suit contemplates urgent interim relief.

    It relied on Dhanbad Fuels Private Limited v. Union of India and Novenco Building and Industry A/S v. Xero Energy Engineering Solutions, and held that the plaint and accompanying documents must be examined from the perspective of the party seeking relief. Failure to ultimately obtain interim relief would not, by itself, defeat the exemption. However, courts must ensure that urgency is not invoked as a pretext to bypass mediation.

    It also observed that mediation seeks to preserve existing relationships between contracting parties. However, infringement and passing off disputes under Section 2(1)(c)(xvii) of the Commercial Courts Act do not ordinarily involve such relationships. It clarified that exemption from mediation is not automatic and depends on the facts of each case, although the yardstick for assessing urgency in such suits would differ.

    The conflicting claims regarding the dates on which the respondents commenced using the mark and Malhotra International discovered the alleged infringement raised questions of fact to be examined at the injunction hearing. The Bench held that these issues need not be determined at the present stage.

    Relying on Novenco, it reiterated that delay, by itself, does not negate urgency when infringement is continuing. Insisting on mediation in such circumstances could leave the aggrieved party without a remedy.

    Further, the judges held that the alleged infringement constituted a continuing wrong and that public interest in preventing deception also warranted consideration. It granted leave under Section 12A and Order II Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. It also directed the respondents to show cause why leave under Clause 14 of the Letters Patent, 1865, should not be granted.

    Moreover, the Division bench considered the Registry's refusal to accept the appellant's injunction application along with the plaint under an office order dated 20 January 2026. It observed that the Bar considered the restriction an impediment to litigants and that it could defeat the purpose of seeking urgent interim relief.

    It also set aside the relevant part of the order and directed the Registry to accept interim applications filed along with plaints, subject to its written objections.

    Accordingly, the High Court allowed Malhotra International to pursue its suit without pre-institution mediation and directed the Registry to accept interim applications filed with plaints.

    For Appellant: Senior Advocate Debnath Ghosh with Advocates Biswaroop Mukherjee and Vishwarup Acharyya

    For Respondents: Advocate Sayantan Roy Chowdhury, Tanmoy Roy and Sohini Mukherjee for R-3.

    Case Title :  Malhotra International Private Limited v. Rohan Malhotra and Ors.Case Number :  TEMPAPO-IPD/7/2026 IA NO: GA-COM/1/2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (CAL) 272
    Next Story