A Non-Jain Firm Cannot Claim Honest Adoption Of Jain God's Name As Trademark: Madras High Court
Riya Rathore
18 Nov 2026 11:43 AM IST

The Madras High Court has observed that a Bengaluru-based hardware firm's proprietor could not prima facie claim to have honestly adopted “NAKODA”, a word referring to a Jain god, as his trademark when he does not belong to the Jain community.
Justice P.B. Balaji made the observation while restraining the Bengaluru firm from infringing the trademarks of a Chennai-based metal hardware manufacturer and passing off its goods under deceptively similar marks.
“Firstly, I see the user of the mark to be dishonest and not bonafide for the simple reason that though NAKODA is a descriptive word referring to a Jain god, the respondent does not even belong to the Jain community to claim to have adopted the mark NAKODA honestly. On the other hand, the applicant has shown the source for coining NAKODA SNE and also shown use for more than a decade now,” the court remarked.
The dispute arose from allegations by Kailash Chand Surana, proprietor of Kalptaru Enterprise, that Shiv Mangal Singh, proprietor of Bengaluru-based AJ and Sons, was using a mark deceptively similar to his trademarks for metal hardware goods.
The business was originally established as a partnership firm in 2007 under the name Sree Nakoda Enterprises. The mark SNE NAKODA was coined using the first letters of the firm's name. Surana has been manufacturing and selling metal screws since October 2017 and holds 14 trademark registrations, including NAKODA PROPLUS and PRO NAKODA in Class 6.
AJ and Sons argued that NAKODA refers to a god and cannot be exclusively claimed by the Chennai manufacturer. It also pointed out that Kalptaru Enterprise had no registration for SNE or SNE NAKODA and that around 30 registrations across different classes used the acronym SNE.
The Bengaluru firm further contended that the two businesses catered to different markets, that it was unaware of Kalptaru Enterprise's business, and that the claims of goodwill and reputation were self-serving.
The court found that Kalptaru Enterprise was the prior user of the mark and that AJ and Sons had failed to substantiate its claimed date of use. Since both firms dealt in metal screws, the similar mark could confuse consumers. The court also found the adoption dishonest and granted interim injunctions restraining infringement and passing off.
For Applicant: Advocate A.Jayesh Kumar Daga
For Respondent: Advocate V.Arunagiri
