Karnataka High Court Allows Withdrawal Of Plea Challenging Whitefield Tower RERA Escrow Conditions

  • Karnataka High Court Allows Withdrawal Of Plea Challenging Whitefield Tower RERA Escrow Conditions

    The Karnataka High Court has permitted the withdrawal of a petition challenging conditions in two no-objection certificates (NOCs) that the petitioners alleged would divert Whitefield Tower homebuyers' payments away from the project's designated RERA escrow account.

    Justice B.M. Shyam Prasad allowed the withdrawal after finding that the company's former managing director had suppressed material developments concerning a change in management and had failed to establish his authority to continue the proceedings on the company's behalf.

    “There is no reference to any of these aspects, and this Court must also observe that the second petitioner is silent about having initiated any proceedings raising a dispute over these Resolutions. These must be fatal and this undermines the second petitioner's right to continue the present petition on behalf of the first petitioner,” the court observed.

    Aubergine Properties Private Limited and its former managing director, Antony Kunnel George, had challenged two NOCs dated January 25, 2021, and May 27, 2024, issued by Kroyana Special Situations Fund, Axis Trustee Services Limited and ANA ARC Private Limited.

    They alleged that the conditions would divert buyer payments away from the designated RERA collection account, bypassing safeguards under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016.

    The petitioners sought a direction that all buyer collections be deposited into the designated RERA collection account, with 70% transferred to another account for land and construction costs. They wanted the remaining 30% maintained in a separate escrow account under RERA supervision or another mechanism directed by the court. Alternatively, they sought directions to the Karnataka Real Estate Regulatory Authority to decide complaints, appeals and representations concerning the project within a fixed time.

    The dispute over George's authority arose from separate proceedings concerning shares pledged with Axis Trustee Services.

    On July 24, 2025, the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Bengaluru, directed the transfer of the pledged shares and entry of Axis Trustee's name in Aubergine's register of shareholders, effective from the date the pledge was revoked.

    George appealed against the order. On November 21, 2025, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal condoned the delay in filing the appeal. Meanwhile, company resolutions recorded the share transfer, appointed Dr. Reddaiah Molakala as the new management and resolved to remove George. The resolutions were not challenged.

    The high court also relied on two earlier proceedings. In a commercial suit, George had consented to the new management representing the company. The commercial court subsequently held that only the new management could represent Aubergine in that suit.

    In another writ petition, the high court quashed a private complaint filed by George on the company's behalf after the new management stated that it did not wish to pursue it.

    Holding that the findings in these proceedings would be conclusive for the present case, the judge found that George had suppressed material developments and that his right to represent the company was undermined.

    The high court permitted Molakala to withdraw the petition and disposed of it as withdrawn. It did not examine the legality of the disputed NOCs.

    For Petitioner (Aubergine Properties Private Limited): Advocates Nandan Karthikeyan, Vijay Prabhu S.

    For Petitioner (Antony Kunnel George): Advocate Ludhveena K. Luthria.

    For Respondents (Kroyana Special Situations Fund, Axis Trustee Services Limited and ANA ARC Private Limited): Advocate Nayana Tara B.G.

    For Applicant (Dr. Reddaiah Molakala): Senior Counsel Aditya Sondhi.

    Case Title :  Aubergine Properties Private Limited and Antony Kunnel George v. Karnataka Real Estate Regulatory Authority and OthersCase Number :  W.P. No. 10696 of 2026 (GM-RES)CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (KAR) 236
    Next Story