NI Act | Cheque Dishonour Due To Bank's Merger Not A Bar To Prosecution: Gauhati High Court

  • NI Act | Cheque Dishonour Due To Banks Merger Not A Bar To Prosecution: Gauhati High Court

    The Gauhati High Court has held that a cheque's dishonour following the merger of the drawee bank cannot by itself, bar prosecution under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.

    The complainant cannot reasonably be expected to know whether checks issued by account holders of the erstwhile Allahabad Bank became invalid after its merger with Indian Bank, as such matters lie within the exclusive knowledge of banking institutions, the Court said.

    Justice Shamima Jahan dismissed a criminal petition filed by Naman Enterprise, seeking to quash a Section 138 cheque dishonour complaint filed by Gopi Mohan Drug Distributor, along with the Magistrate's order dated October 16, 2025, taking cognizance and the subsequent order dated July 24, 2026 issuing a bailable warrant.

    "The complainant could not be reasonably expected to know that cheques issued by Account holders of the erstwhile Allahabad Bank, had become invalid after the merger and that the Indian Bank was under no obligation to honour such cheques. These are matters lying within the exclusive knowledge of the concerned banking institutions and cannot, by themselves, be a ground for a bar to a suit under Section 138 of the Act.", the Court said.

    The dispute arose from business transactions involving the supply of medicines and surgical items on credit. The complainant alleged that ₹75,650 remained unpaid and that Naman Enterprise issued a cheque dated December 4, 2024, drawn on the erstwhile Allahabad Bank, Mangaldoi Branch. The cheque was returned unpaid with the remark “Bank merged”. The complainant issued a legal notice on December 26, 2024 demanding payment within 15 days. Following non payment, case was instituted.

    The court observed that the complainant could not be presumed to know the legal or contractual consequences of the merger of Allahabad Bank with Indian Bank. The cheque's return on that ground, therefore could not independently defeat the complaint.

    The Bench further declined to examine the petitioner's ledger account, which allegedly showed that no legally enforceable debt existed, since the complainant disputed it.

    Such disputed factual questions were not appropriate for determination in proceedings seeking quashing.

    The Court held that whether the cheque represented a legally recoverable debt or was merely a security cheque must be examined by the trial court on the basis of evidence, while considering the statutory presumption in favour of the cheque holder.

    It accordingly declined to interfere with the complaint and dismissed the criminal petition.

    For the Petitioner: Advocate W. Raja,

    For the Respondent No. 2: Advocate M. Agarwalla,

    For the State: M.P. Goswami, Additional Public Prosecutor.

    Case Title :  M/S NAMAN ENTERPRISE vs THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ANRCase Number :  Crl.Pet./1219/2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (GAU) 39
    Next Story