SARFAESI | Alleged Notice To Deceased Person Not Ground For Cross-Examining Bank Officer: Calcutta HC

  • SARFAESI | Alleged Notice To Deceased Person Not Ground For Cross-Examining Bank Officer: Calcutta HC

    The Calcutta High Court has held that allegations that a bank issued a sale notice in the name of a deceased person or relied on postal receipts and tracking records from an earlier failed auction cannot by themselves justify cross examination of the bank's authorised officer in proceedings under the SARFAESI Act.

    Justice Om Narayan Rai made the observation while disposing of a revisional application filed by Jatadhari Rice Mill and another challenging the Debts Recovery Tribunal's rejection of their application seeking cross-examination of the bank's authorised officer in a SARFAESI dispute.

    "The petitioners' assertion that the bank has issued notice in the name of a dead person and that the bank has used the postal receipt and postal track records pertaining to an earlier failed sale in order to support its claim of issuance of notice in respect of the present sale cannot be a ground to seek cross examination.", the Court said.

    Jatadhari Rice Mill had availed credit facilities from the erstwhile Oriental Bank of Commerce which merged with Punjab National Bank and mortgaged properties to secure the loans. Following alleged defaults, the bank initiated SARFAESI proceedings and took steps to auction the secured assets.

    The borrowers challenged the measures before the DRT, Siliguri. They filed two applications in 2025 seeking production of original documents and examination of the bank's authorised officer. While the Tribunal allowed the application for production of documents, it rejected the request for examination by an order dated June 29, 2026. The borrowers approached the High Court.

    The Court observed that the Tribunal had already permitted the borrowers to inspect the original documents relating to the loan account and SARFAESI proceedings.

    It held that the Tribunal could examine these documents to determine whether the bank had followed the procedure prescribed under the SARFAESI Act, 2002 and the Rules framed thereunder. Therefore, cross examination was not necessary to ascertain the truth.

    The Court further held that the borrowers' allegation that the bank had falsely claimed compliance with the statutory procedure could also be examined by the Tribunal on the basis of the documents produced by the parties. Cross examination was not required for that purpose either.

    Noting that the SARFAESI application had been pending for more than two years, the Court requested the DRT to dispose of it expeditiously, preferably within six months from the next date of hearing, without granting unnecessary adjournments.

    The revisional application was accordingly disposed of with no order as to costs.

    For the Petitioners: Advocates Rishav Das, Rinka Chakraborty and Samrat Acharya

    For Punjab National Bank: Advocates Tapas Paul and Pritam Ray

    Case Title :  Jatadhari Rice Mill & Anr. Vs. Punjab National Bank, ARMB, Murshidabad & AnrCase Number :  CO.136 of 2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (CAL) 275
    Next Story