Madras High Court Upholds Refusal Of TVS Motor's Patent For Fuel Tank-Mounted Biometric System To Identify Riders
Riya Rathore
16 Nov 2026 5:10 PM IST

The Madras High Court has dismissed an appeal filed by TVS Motor Company Limited against the refusal of its patent application for a vehicle with a biometric user recognition system mounted on the fuel tank assembly.
Justice K. Kumaresh Babu observed that merely placing an existing biometric identification device on a different surface of a vehicle cannot make an invention new. The judge held, "Just a placement of the bio-metric identification device on a different surface of the vehicle cannot do away with the prior cited documents to hold that the claim made by the appellant is a new invention."
TVS filed its patent application on February 7, 2018, for an invention titled 'A Vehicle', comprising 11 claims. It proposed mounting a biometric recognition system, using fingerprint, voice, or retina recognition, on the top surface of the fuel tank assembly.
The company argued that this position made the system easier for riders to access and reduced physical strain. It also claimed that the arrangement simplified the vehicle's wiring harness, improved its durability and made the system theft-proof.
The Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs rejected the application on July 19, 2024, citing lack of inventive step under Section 2(1)(ja) of the Patents Act, 1970, and exclusion under Section 3(f). The latter provision excludes mere arrangements or rearrangements of known devices that function independently in a known manner.
Challenging the refusal, TVS argued that the Patent Office had failed to assess the invention as a whole. It maintained that the technical advancement lay not merely in relocating the biometric system but also in integrating it with the vehicle's wiring harness to simplify the wiring and improve its reliability.
The company pointed out that the two prior art documents relied on by the Patent Office disclosed biometric devices at different locations. D1 described a fingerprint identification device on the handlebar or its rear cover, while D2 disclosed one inside a glove box beneath the seat. Neither proposed mounting the system on the fuel tank assembly, TVS contended.
The Patent Office opposed the appeal, arguing that relocating an existing biometric authentication system did not produce any new or improved technical result. The biometric system, along with its wiring and authentication functions, was already disclosed in the cited documents, although at different locations on the vehicle.
The court noted that TVS had acknowledged that similar features were already available. Its claim was based on placing the system in a more advantageous position. However, the judge observed that technical advantages over existing prior art could not, by themselves, make an invention new.
The court also observed that documents D1 and D2 were identical to the claimed invention except for the placement of the biometric recognition system. Merely moving the device to another surface of the vehicle was not enough to disregard the cited prior art, it held.
Finding that the invention was obvious to a person skilled in the art, the court dismissed the appeal. It also closed the connected miscellaneous petition, with no order as to costs.
For TVS Motor: Advocate Damodar Vaidya for Deepika Murali
For Respondent: SPCGSC A.R.Sakthivel
