Value Preservation Cannot Justify Revival Of Company After Liquidation Begins: NCLT Mumbai

  • Value Preservation Cannot Justify Revival Of Company After Liquidation Begins: NCLT Mumbai

    The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) at Mumbai has held that preserving a company's value, including its intangible assets, cannot justify invoking its inherent powers to revive the company once liquidation has commenced.

    The tribunal made this observation while dismissing an application by Essar Shipping Limited to revive OGD Services Limited as a going concern.

    It noted that an October 14, 2025 amendment to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI) Liquidation Process Regulations removed the provision for selling a corporate debtor as a going concern in cases where such a sale had not already commenced.

    “Consequently, value preservation, including that of intangible assets cannot not serve as a valid justification within the liquidation process for exercising inherent powers,” the tribunal observed.

    A Bench of Judicial Member K.R. Saji Kumar and Technical Member Anil Raj Chellan further held that the absence of a statutory provision permitting withdrawal or settlement during liquidation could not be overcome by invoking inherent powers.

    “We cannot lose sight of the conspicuous absence of any provision that allows withdrawal or settlement during the liquidation process. The recent legislative changes also fail to indicate a preference for preserving the corporate debtor as a going concern, even at the risk of losing the value of intangible assets and a substantial reduction in the realisation,” the tribunal noted

    It held that its inherent powers could not be exercised to permit withdrawal during liquidation, as doing so would confer substantive rights on persons who would otherwise be ineligible to submit a resolution plan under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC).

    Essar Shipping, the holding company and corporate guarantor of OGD Services, had sought to revive the company under its management, recall the liquidation order dated April 29, 2024, and also withdraw the underlying insolvency proceedings.

    Punjab National Bank (PNB) had initiated insolvency proceedings against OGD Services. The NCLT admitted the company into CIRP on February 9, 2023. As no compliant resolution plan was received, the creditors decided to go ahead with liquidation of the company. The tribunal ordered liquidation on April 29, 2024.

    Essar Shipping subsequently settled the dues of both financial creditors, PNB and Union Bank of India (UBI). PNB issued a no-dues certificate in November 2025, while UBI issued one in December 2024.

    Essar Shipping also told the tribunal that it had settled or acquired 80% of the admitted operational creditor claims, worth ₹13.88 crore. It undertook to clear the remaining dues and bear the CIRP and liquidation costs if the company was revived. It argued that liquidation was still at an early stage, with no assets sold or distributions made.

    The tribunal, however, noted that Section 12A of the IBC permits withdrawal of insolvency proceedings during CIRP, but contains no provision for withdrawal once liquidation begins.

    It also noted that although Regulation 2B permits compromise or arrangements under Section 230 of the Companies Act, persons ineligible to submit resolution plans under the IBC cannot participate in such arrangements. Citing the Supreme Court's rulings in Arun Kumar Jagatramka, Ebix Singapore and Independent Sugar Corporation, the Bench held that inherent powers cannot be used to create a remedy that the law does not provide.

    It accordingly dismissed Essar Shipping's application.

    For Essar Shipping Limited: Senior Advocate Gaurav Joshi along with Advocates Ativ Patel, Pawan Kulkarni and Viraj Raiyani, instructed by AVP Partners

    For the Respondent: Advocate Aniruth Purusothaman

    Case Title :  Essar Shipping Limited v/s. Jayanti Lal Jain & Ors.Case Number :  I.A. No. 915 of 2026 IN C.P. (IB) No. 17/MB/2019CITATION :  2026 LLBiz NCLT (MUM) 1144
    Next Story