NCLT Mumbai Rejects IL&FS Guarantor's Challenge To Insolvency Report In ₹260 Crore Debt Case
Kirit Singhania
21 Nov 2026 2:40 PM IST

The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Mumbai, on 20 November dismissed two applications filed by Unmesh Manohar Joshi challenging the Resolution Professional's report recommending insolvency proceedings against him as a personal guarantor for a debt of Rs. 260 crore owed to IL&FS Financial Services Ltd.
A Bench of Judicial Member Ashish Kalia and Technical Member Banwari Lal Meena held that the Resolution Professional had complied with Section 99 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) and had not violated any interim orders passed by the Supreme Court or the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT). It said:
“Since the Applicant has already failed to made out its case in the main Application and the fact that the communication made by the Respondent No. 2 through emails dated 21.09.2023 is clearly evident in the present matter, it shows that there is no merit in allowing the said Interlocutory Application i.e., IA (I.B.C) No. 4085/MB/2024. Thus, issue (ii) is also decided against the Applicant.”
IL&FS Financial Services had initiated proceedings under Section 95 of the IBC against Joshi, who was the Chairman and Managing Director of Kohinoor Housing Development Pvt. Ltd. and its personal guarantor, over an alleged default of Rs. 260.31 crore, including principal dues of Rs. 120 crore. The date of default was stated as 6 April 2018.
Joshi subsequently challenged the constitutional validity of Section 95 before the Supreme Court. The NCLT appointed Shailesh Pranlal Bhuta as the Resolution Professional on 28 August 2023. Following the proceedings before the Supreme Court and the NCLAT, Bhuta filed his report under Section 99 on 2 January 2024.
The Resolution Professional had emailed Joshi on 21 September 2023, seeking information and proof of repayment of the alleged outstanding debt. The report was also sent to the same email address.
Although Joshi acknowledged receipt of the report, he failed to establish that the earlier email seeking information had not been delivered. The Tribunal held that service through email was valid, noting that Joshi could not deny receipt of one communication while acknowledging another sent to the same address.
Further, the Bench noted that the Supreme Court, in Dilip Jiwrajka v. Union of India, had upheld the constitutional validity of Section 95. It also noted that the NCLAT, on 6 December 2023, had vacated the stay on the Resolution Professional's proceedings.
Finding that Bhuta had acted in accordance with Section 99 of the IBC, it found no grounds to quash his report or replace him.
Accordingly, the NCLT dismissed both applications.
For the Applicant: Advocates Akshay Patil, Rohan Agarwal and Neha Patil, instructed by Advocate Akshay V. Kamble
For IL&FS: Advocates Amir Arsiwala, Akash Jain, Sanjana Salvi and Divyang Salvi, instructed by Mansukhlal Hiralal & Co.
For the Resolution Professional: Advocates Vamsh Shetty, Rishabh Dhanuka and Mahima Shah, instructed by Agarwal & Dhanuka Legal
