NCLT Mumbai Dismisses Plea Against Bauxite Seller As Contract Did Not Specify Who Pays Demurrage
Mohd.Rehan Ali
18 Nov 2026 6:54 PM IST

The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Mumbai Bench, has recently dismissed an insolvency petition filed by Oceanic Trade Minerals Pvt. Ltd. against Arisinfra Solutions Pvt. Ltd.
It ruled that Clause 14(E) of their contract did not establish the seller's liability to pay demurrage charges because it did not specify which party was responsible for them.
The bench comprising Judicial Member Lakshmi Gurung and Technical Member Hariharan Neelakanta Iyer observed that the clause provided for demurrage settlement but did not identify whether the buyer or seller would be liable.
“neither the Statement of facts nor the letters makes any express mention about the accrual of demurrage charges or the liability of the seller (Respondent) towards demurrage charges. The documents placed on record by the Petitioner do not stipulate as to who would be responsible for delays caused by detention at the load port,” the tribunal observed.
Oceanic approached the tribunal seeking CIRP against Arisinfra over alleged unpaid demurrage of USD 131,948.78 (approximately ₹1.08 crore).
Under a January 16, 2023, contract, Arisinfra had agreed to sell bauxite to Oceanic. The first consignment of 55,000 WMT was loaded onto M.V. Vishva Diksha at Umroli (Bankot) Port, Maharashtra. Oceanic claimed that loading took 10.15.28 days against the permitted laytime of 6.21 days.
It relied on Clause 14(E), which provided for demurrage as per the Charter Party if loading exceeded the permitted laytime. However, the tribunal found that the clause did not say whether the buyer or seller was responsible for paying it.
It also went on to note that the Fixture Note, which set the demurrage rate at USD 35,000 PDPR/HD, was an agreement between Oceanic and the vessel owner, Shakti Shipping and Trading Pte. Ltd. Arisinfra was not a party to it.
Oceanic had not raised an invoice and, more importantly, had not even sent its February 26, 2024 debit note to Arisinfra. The NCLT also rejected the argument that Arisinfra's failure to reply to the demand notice amounted to an admission of liability, relying on Greymatter Entertainment and Navin Madhavji Mehta.
Finding no material to show that Arisinfra had agreed to pay demurrage, the tribunal dismissed the insolvency plea.
For Operational Creditor: Advocates Ashwin Shanker and Diksha Brahma
For Corporate Debtor: Advocates Nausher Kohli and Ankit Pitti
