Co-Borrower's Independent Repayment Liability Cannot Be Equated With Personal Guarantee: NCLT Mumbai

  • Co-Borrowers Independent Repayment Liability Cannot Be Equated With Personal Guarantee: NCLT Mumbai

    The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Mumbai, on 19 November held that a co-borrower's repayment liability cannot be treated as a personal guarantee obligation merely because the individual has also guaranteed another entity's debt.

    A Bench comprising Judicial Member Sushil Mahadeorao Kochey and Technical Member Prabhat Kumar admitted a personal insolvency application filed by Narendra Mithailal Agarwal under Section 94 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, arising from his personal guarantee for a Rs. 19.61 crore default by Rajrani Steel Casting Private Limited. It said:

    “An individual may incur financial liabilities in different capacities, including as a borrower, co-borrower or personal guarantor. The mere fact that an individual has furnished a personal guarantee in respect of the debt of one Corporate Debtor does not result in all other financial liabilities undertaken by such individual in his personal capacity being treated as liabilities arising under a contract of guarantee.”

    Rajrani Steel Casting had availed a cash credit facility of Rs. 13 crore and a term loan of Rs. 6.61 crore from Bank of India in 2024. Agarwal executed a deed of personal guarantee on 19 September 2024.

    Following the default, the bank classified the account as a non-performing asset on 29 March 2026 and issued a demand notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act on 30 March 2026. Agarwal subsequently filed the Section 94 application in respect of the Rs. 19.61 crore default.

    The Tribunal noted that a separate Business Loan Agreement dated 15 July 2025 showed that Agarwal had also undertaken liability as a co-borrower along with the Corporate Debtor. It observed that this was an independent repayment obligation and could not be equated with liability under a contract of guarantee.

    It rejected the contention that Agarwal had filed the application merely to obstruct SARFAESI recovery proceedings. It noted that the bank had classified the account as an NPA on 29 March 2026, issued the demand notice the following day, recalled the loan facilities on 8 April and initiated further enforcement measures, including issuing an auction notice on 4 June 2026.

    Further, the Bench distinguished the NCLAT decision in Syed Sirajis Salikin Khadri v. Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd., which involved a Section 94 application filed nearly a decade after default and coinciding with possession proceedings. Relying on its decision in Nirmal D Jain, it noted that the present case was distinguishable, as the financial creditor had acted swiftly after the default.

    It directed Resolution Professional Sahil Shanker Agarwal to publish a public notice within seven days, inviting creditors to submit their claims within 21 days. Agarwal was also directed to deposit Rs. 75,000 towards the Resolution Professional's fees and expenses. It also directed the Registry to communicate the order to the Resolution Professional and upload it within seven working days.

    Accordingly, the NCLT admitted the application under Section 100 of the IBC and initiated insolvency resolution proceedings against Agarwal, declaring a moratorium for 180 days.

    For the Applicant: Advocate Karan Singh

    For the Resolution Professional: Advocate Krish Shah

    For L&T Finance: Advocates Mily Ghoshal and Shweta Thaneka

    Case Title :  In the matter of NARENDRA MITHAILAL AGARWALCase Number :  C.P. (IB) NO. 806/MB/2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz NCLT (MUM) 1153
    Next Story