Mere Receipt Of Insurance Premium Does Not Establish Accrual Of Income For Insurer: ITAT Delhi

  • Mere Receipt Of Insurance Premium Does Not Establish Accrual Of Income For Insurer: ITAT Delhi

    The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Delhi Bench, has held that mere receipt of an insurance premium does not necessarily mean that income has accrued to the insurer when the amount is subject to conditions governing acceptance of insurance risk. It also clarified that showing the amount as a current liability in the accounts is not, by itself, conclusive.

    A Bench of Judicial Member Kavitha Rajagopal and Accountant Member Renu Jauhari observed:

    “We find that the mere receipt of money does not necessarily establish accrual of income where the amount is received subject to conditions governing acceptance of insurance risk. At the same time, classification of the amount as a current liability in the accounts is not, by itself, conclusive. The treatment must be supported by the applicable IRDAI regulations, PMFBY guidelines and the underlying insurance arrangements.”

    The tribunal made these observations while upholding the deletion of a ₹208.32 crore addition made against Agriculture Insurance Company of India Ltd. towards unallocated premium collections under the Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY) for Assessment Year 2020-21.

    The dispute arose from an addition made by the Assessing Officer while assessing the insurer for the year. The AO added ₹208,32,70,000 to its income on the ground that the premium collections received during the year had not been credited to the Profit and Loss Account. Instead, the insurer had shown the amount under current liabilities.

    The insurer explained that the collections represented premiums remitted by banks for which underwriting had not been completed and the corresponding insurance risk had not commenced. It submitted that the requisite details of insured farmers had to be uploaded and validated on the National Crop Insurance Portal and the insurance proposals accepted before the premium could be recognised as income.

    According to the insurer, the amounts remained unallocated due to incomplete or incorrect particulars furnished by banks, Aadhaar mismatches, non-notified crops or areas, revised notifications issued by state governments, and excess or incorrect remittances.

    The insurer further submitted that, under the Insurance Act, 1938, applicable IRDAI regulations, and its accounting policies, premium deposits for which the insurance risk had not commenced were shown as current liabilities. It also relied on Section 44 of the Income Tax Act read with Rule 5 of the First Schedule, which provides for a special method of computing the profits and gains of general insurance business.

    The tribunal observed that the accounting treatment had to be supported by the applicable IRDAI regulations, PMFBY guidelines and underlying insurance arrangements. Merely classifying an amount as a current liability would not, by itself, settle the question of its tax treatment.

    It also found that the Assessing Officer had not identified any specific infirmity in the insurer's accounting policy or established that the insurance risk corresponding to the disputed premium collections had commenced during the relevant previous year.

    The tribunal observed, “In the absence of such a finding, the accounting treatment consistently adopted by the assessee in accordance with the applicable regulatory framework cannot be disregarded merely because the premium amounts were received during the year.”

    It further noted that Section 44, read with Rule 5 of the First Schedule, required due consideration of the special method prescribed for computing the profits and gains of general insurance business.

    The tribunal held that the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) was justified in accepting the accounting treatment followed by the insurer. It found that the Revenue had not established any material basis to disturb that treatment or recognise the entire ₹208.32 crore as income during the year. It accordingly upheld the deletion of the addition and dismissed the Revenue's ground.

    The consolidated order dealt with cross-appeals by the Revenue and the insurer for Assessment Years 2020-21 and 2022-23, as well as the Revenue's appeals for Assessment Years 2021-22 and 2023-24. The tribunal dismissed the Revenue's appeals and allowed the insurer's appeals for statistical purposes.

    For Assessee: Gopal Aggarwal, CA

    For Revenue: Dr. Rajinder Kaur, CIT-DR; Tarun Sharda, Senior DR

    Case Title :  ACIT v. Agriculture Insurance Company of India Ltd.Case Number :  ITA Nos. 7816, 7654, 7655 and 7817/Del/2025; ITA Nos. 7996 and 7997/Del/2025CITATION :  2026 LLBiz ITAT(DEL) 309
    Next Story