Loan From NBFC Linked To Alleged Accommodation Entry Operators Not Bogus Without Evidence: ITAT Delhi

  • Loan From NBFC Linked To Alleged Accommodation Entry Operators Not Bogus Without Evidence: ITAT Delhi

    The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Delhi Bench, has upheld the deletion of a ₹2 crore addition after finding that the Assessing Officer had not established any connection between the loan and the lender's alleged accommodation-entry activities.

    The bench comprising Vice President Mahavir Singh and Accountant Member Manish Agarwal held that the lender's association with alleged entry operators and a search conducted at their premises in 2010 could not, by itself, establish that the loan received in Assessment Year 2015-16 was an accommodation entry.

    The assessee, Ellora Infratech Pvt. Ltd., had received the loan from Mekastar Finlease Ltd., an NBFC registered with the Reserve Bank of India. The Assessing Officer questioned the transaction because the lender belonged to Surender Kumar Jain and Virender Kumar Jain.

    Their premises were searched on April 19, 2010, when documents indicating their involvement in providing accommodation entries were found. However, the tribunal found that the search proceedings related to Financial Year 2010-11 and had no connection with the loan received by the assessee in Assessment Year 2015-16.

    It also noted that the AO had not identified any incriminating document linking the assessee or the lender to an accommodation-entry transaction. Although Mekastar Finlease did not respond to a notice issued under Section 133(6), the notice was not returned unserved. The assessee, however, failed to produce the lender's director when asked by the AO.

    Before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), the assessee furnished the lender's income-tax returns, loan confirmation, agreement, bank statements and ledger account. It also submitted documents showing repayment of the loan with interest and deduction of TDS.

    The AO's remand report did not dispute the merits of these documents. The tribunal held that the assessee had established the lender's identity and creditworthiness and the genuineness of the loan.

    “In view of above, the assessee has established the identity, creditworthiness and genuineness of the transaction of the loan taken from M/s Mekastart Finlease Ltd. [sic], thus AO is not justified disbelieving the same,” it observed.

    The tribunal also upheld the deletion of a separate addition of ₹32.94 lakh towards interest paid to RKG Finvest Ltd., another NBFC managed and controlled by the Jain brothers.

    The assessee had claimed interest expenditure of ₹37.13 lakh. The AO disallowed ₹32,94,247, alleging that the payment was made in lieu of cash. He relied on the lender's pattern of writing off bad debts, its security premium of ₹490 crore and negative reserves and surplus.

    The tribunal noted that the assessee had furnished details of interest payments and TDS returns. The interest was paid through account-payee cheques after deduction of TDS under Section 194A.

    It also noted that the assessee had received a ₹2 crore loan from RKG Finvest in FY 2012-13. The AO had accepted the loan and allowed interest of ₹17,68,767 paid on it after TDS deduction.

    Finding no adverse material against the interest payments, the tribunal upheld the deletion of the ₹32.94 lakh disallowance and dismissed the Revenue's appeal.

    For Assessee: Senior Advocate Prem Lata Bansal, Advocate Shivang Bansal

    For Revenue: Balkishan Gopal, Senior Departmental Representative

    Case Title :  Income Tax Officer v. Ellora Infratech Pvt. Ltd.Case Number :  ITA No. 7336/Del/2019CITATION :  2026 LLBiz ITAT(DEL) 308
    Next Story