Handmade Jewellery Exports From SEZ Unit Eligible For Income Tax Exemption: ITAT Delhi
Mehak Dhiman
16 Nov 2026 5:28 PM IST

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Delhi Bench, has allowed a jewellery manufacturer's appeal. It held that the use of hand tools, karigars and contract labour instead of substantial manufacturing machinery does not disqualify its handmade jewellery manufacturing activities from tax exemption.
A Bench comprising Vice President Mahavir Singh and Accountant Member Manish Agarwal held that the assessee fulfilled the conditions for claiming deduction under Section 10AA of the Income Tax Act, 1961, as the manufacturing activities were carried out within its Special Economic Zone (SEZ) unit in Noida.
The Tribunal observed that the provision requires an undertaking to manufacture or produce articles or things. However, it does not mandate the use of machinery.
It observed that the manufacturing activity carried out by karigars and contract labour within the SEZ premises constituted manufacturing by the SEZ unit.
The assessee, M/s Bikram Exports, was engaged in the manufacture and export of jewellery from its unit situated in the Noida SEZ.
The Assessing Officer (AO) denied the exemption claimed under Section 10AA, primarily on the ground that the assessee had negligible machinery and fixed assets despite reporting a substantial turnover of approximately ₹53 crore.
The AO noted that the value of machinery was only ₹21,927 and questioned how the assessee could have undertaken manufacturing activities on such a scale. The AO also relied on production expenses of approximately ₹4.94 crore and tax deducted at source under Section 194C to conclude that the manufacturing activity had been outsourced.
The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) upheld the disallowance, also referring to the requirements relating to subcontracting under Rule 41 of the Special Economic Zones Rules, 2006.
Before the Tribunal, the assessee submitted that it manufactured handmade jewellery using hand tools and simple implements, and that the work was carried out by karigars and contract labour within the SEZ premises.
It contended that the mere absence of substantial machinery could not lead to the conclusion that no manufacturing activity was undertaken.
On the issue of designs and production processes, the assessee explained that the designs and templates were provided by foreign customers and constituted confidential and proprietary information. It was therefore not possible to disclose all such designs without the customers' consent. The assessee also pointed out that its books of account had not been rejected by the AO.
The Tribunal accepted the assessee's submissions and observed that Section 10AA does not prescribe any requirement that manufacturing must necessarily be carried out through machinery. The statutory requirement is that the undertaking should manufacture or produce articles or things.
It further observed that the use of skilled workers, including karigars and contract labour, within the SEZ premises could not be treated as outsourcing of manufacturing activity outside the SEZ.
The Tribunal noted that the movement of materials was subject to Customs supervision and that the assessee had produced records relating to the receipt of gold and export of finished goods.
"..neither man nor material can enter or exit the SEZ without the approval and attestation of the customs authorities posted at the entry and exit gates of the SEZ. Therefore, the 'inescapable conclusion' as stated to have been arraived at Assissing Officer 'that the production activity is not conducted in-house by the Assessee firm at its unit in Noida' is erroneous", it said.
The Tribunal also accepted the assessee's explanation regarding the confidentiality of foreign customers' designs and noted that common designs and templates had been produced before the authorities.
It observed that the assessee had undertaken export transactions and received the corresponding export proceeds.
Accordingly, the Tribunal held that the disallowance of the exemption under Section 10AA was not justified and directed that the exemption be allowed for the relevant assessment years.
"..the Assessing Officer records that the assessee had carried out huge exports to the tune of Rs. 253 crores. In actual fact, the exports were only to the tune of Rs. 53 crores as elsewhere mentioned by the Assessing Officer herself in the impugned order. In view of the above, the claim of the assessee for exemption under Section 10AA of the Act is allowed", it said.
For Assessment Year 2016-17, the Tribunal also considered the disallowance of bonus expenditure amounting to ₹16,13,250. The assessee had furnished details of employees along with acquittance rolls to substantiate the payment.
The authorities had noted a difference between the amount of ₹16,11,450 reflected in the tax audit report and the amount of ₹16,13,250 supported by the documents furnished by the assessee. The Tribunal treated the difference of ₹2,000 as a clerical error, particularly since no specific defect had been identified in the supporting evidence.
The Tribunal accordingly allowed the assessee's claim for bonus expenditure as well.
The appeals for both assessment years were allowed.
For the Assessee: Advocate K. Sampath
For Revenue: Raghubir Singh, Senior Departmental Representative
