S.153 Income Tax Act | Search Assessments Based On Pre-Existing Documents Would Give Revenue 'Unbridled Power': Delhi HC
Kapil Dhyani
19 Nov 2026 12:52 PM IST

The Delhi High Court has observed that allowing the Income Tax Department to invoke Section 153A of the Income Tax Act on the basis of documents already in its possession, without recovering any material during a search connecting or corroborating those documents, would give the Revenue unbridled and unfettered powers.
The division bench of Justices Subramonium Prasad and Renu Bhatnagar held that documents already available with the Revenue, which were neither recovered nor corroborated by material found during a search, could not form the basis for additions under Section 153A in respect of a completed assessment.
"This Court is of the opinion that if Section 153A of the Income Tax Act is interpreted in a manner which permits notice to be given on the basis of a document which is neither found during the search nor is it a document which, although found during search, does not connect or corroborate the incriminating document already in possession of the authorities, then Section 153A is capable of being abused giving unbridled, unfettered power to the Revenue," the Court observed.
A search and seizure operation was conducted at Petitioner-taxpayer's residence during which the authorities confronted him with a seven-page document allegedly showing that he was the beneficial owner of an HSBC Bank account in Switzerland.
However, the document was already in the possession of the Income Tax Department and had not been recovered during the search.
Subsequently, the Assessing Officer initiated proceedings under Section 153A and made an addition of approximately ₹1.20 crore to Petitioner's income under Section 69 of the Income Tax Act, treating it as an undisclosed foreign bank deposit.
The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) upheld the addition. In the first round of proceedings, the ITAT remanded the matter to the Assessing Officer for verification of the foreign bank documents. In the subsequent round, the ITAT upheld the Revenue's action.
Before the High Court, Petitioner argued that no incriminating material pertaining to the alleged Swiss bank account had been recovered during the search and therefore the Department could not invoke Section 153A merely by relying on documents already in its possession.
The Revenue on the other hand argued that it was not necessary for the relevant documents to have been recovered during the search, particularly when material concerning the alleged foreign bank account was already available with the Department.
Accepting the Petitioner's contention, the High Court noted that the search had resulted only in the recovery of certain jewellery and no document concerning the alleged HSBC account had been recovered.
The Court relied on the Supreme Court's judgment in CIT v. Abhisar Buildwell Private Limited and the Delhi High Court's ruling in CIT v. Kabul Chawla, which recognise that additions to completed assessments under Section 153A require incriminating material unearthed during the search.
The Court clarified that the Revenue was not left without a remedy merely because it could not invoke Section 153A.
"This Court is of the view that it is open for the Revenue to reopen assessment on the basis of any other provision in the Act placing reliance on the document which came to the possession of the Revenue authorities but recourse to issuing notice under Section 153A cannot be resorted to in these matters," it held.
It further observed that the ITAT had erred in remanding the matter for verification of the foreign bank documents when those documents had not been recovered during the search and no material connecting them to the assessee had been found.
As such, the Court allowed both appeals and set aside the assessment action.
For Appellant: Advocates Satyen Sethi, Arta Trana Panda, Gargi Sethee,
For Respondent: Shlok Chandra, SSC with Advocates Naincy Jain, JSC, Udit Dad and Ujjwal Jain,
