Income Tax Department Cannot Sustain Tax Demand After Missing Fresh Assessment Deadline: Punjab & Haryana HC

  • Transfer case, matrimonial dispute, Punjab and Haryana high court, Allowed, Favour Of Wife,  Grants Relief, Husband, Brain Cancer,

    The Punjab and Haryana High Court has ruled that the Income Tax Department cannot enforce a tax demand or continue penalty proceedings if it fails to pass a fresh assessment order within the statutory deadline after the ITAT remits the case for reconsideration.

    Section 153(3) prescribes the time limit for doing so.

    A division bench of Justice Deepak Sibal and Justice Sunish Bindlish allowed a petition filed by Orange Business Services India Solutions Pvt. Ltd., holding that the department could no longer reassess the company after the statutory time limit had expired.

    "Therefore, the revenue is now barred from passing any such assessment order. Consequently, the petitioner's Income Tax Return originally filed on 30.11.2018 is required to be accepted," the court observed.

    The dispute arose from transfer pricing adjustments made to the company's international transactions for the assessment year 2018-19. The ITAT, in an order dated May 30, 2023, deleted an adjustment of ₹24.57 crore relating to interest on receivables and remitted the determination of the arm's length price of certain other international transactions to the Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO) for fresh consideration.

    However, the TPO did not pass a fresh order. The department continued to reflect an outstanding demand of ₹31.97 crore on the income tax portal and issued penalty notices.

    The company contended that the limitation period under Section 153(3) had expired. It submitted that the ITAT's order had been brought to the TPO's notice through a representation dated August 9, 2023.

    The Revenue argued that limitation would begin only when the order was received by the specified senior departmental officers, including the jurisdictional Commissioner of Income Tax.

    Rejecting this argument, the court noted that a Commissioner of Income Tax had been present when the ITAT pronounced its order. A copy had also been handed over to the office of the Senior Departmental Representative. Relying on the Delhi High Court's decision in CIT v. Odeon Builders (P) Ltd., the bench held that internal administrative delays in communicating the order could not operate to the company's prejudice.

    The court also noted that the TPO had been informed of the ITAT's directions but failed to make a fresh determination within the prescribed period. Without such determination, the Assessing Officer could not pass a fresh assessment order.

    Since the original assessment order, which contained the satisfaction for initiating penalty proceedings, had been set aside by the ITAT, the consequential penalty proceedings could not survive, the court held, relying on the Supreme Court's decision in CIT v. Jai Laxmi Rice Mills.

    The court directed the department to delete the outstanding demand from the income tax portal and quashed the notice under Section 221(1) and two notices under Section 274 read with Section 270A.

    For Petitioner: Senior Advocate Radhika Suri, along with Advocates Abhinav Narang and Sidhant Suri

    For Revenue: Senior Standing Counsel Varun Issar and Junior Standing Counsel Nikita Garg appeared for the Revenue.

    Case Title :  Orange Business Services India Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax & Ors.Case Number :  CWP No. 23027 of 2026 (O&M)CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC(PNH) 66
    Next Story