Bank Credits Cannot Be Treated As Undisclosed Turnover Without Evidence Of Sales: ITAT Mumbai

  • Bank Credits Cannot Be Treated As Undisclosed Turnover Without Evidence Of Sales: ITAT Mumbai

    The Mumbai Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), on 2 November held that aggregate bank credits cannot be treated as undisclosed business turnover without evidence establishing that they represent sales or commercial receipts.

    A Bench comprising Judicial Member Sandeep Gosain and Accountant Member Bijayananda Pruseth allowed an appeal filed by Eva Sporting Aspirations Private Limited for Assessment Year 2015-16, and deleted additions of Rs. 3.60 crore under Section 68 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and Rs. 1.25 crore towards estimated gross profit. It observed:

    “In the facts and circumstances of the present case, we are of the considered view that the assessee has discharged the primary burden cast upon it under section 68 by furnishing adequate documentary evidence establishing the identity of the creditors, genuineness of the transactions and financial particulars of the lenders.”

    The Assessing Officer (AO) had reopened the company's assessment based on information received from the Kolkata Investigation Wing alleging that certain entities had routed accommodation entries through intermediary companies.

    Moreover, the AO treated unsecured loans of Rs. 2.80 crore received from Bhuvneshwari Vyapaar Private Limited and Rs. 80 lakh received from Saransh Construction Private Limited as unexplained credits under Section 68.

    Further, the AO noticed aggregate bank credits of Rs. 28.64 crore, although the company had declared nil business turnover. After excluding the Rs. 3.60 crore added under Section 68, the AO treated the remaining Rs. 25.04 crore as undisclosed business turnover, rejected the books of account and estimated gross profit at 5%, resulting in a further addition of Rs. 1.25 crore.

    The company contended that it had furnished the lenders' PAN and corporate details, income tax return acknowledgements, audited financial statements, loan confirmations, ledger accounts and bank statements to establish the identity and genuineness of the transactions. It also pointed out that the loans had subsequently been repaid.

    It also submitted that the AO had relied on a third-party statement without furnishing a copy to the company or providing an opportunity to cross-examine the person concerned, despite a specific request.

    The Revenue maintained that the investigation had uncovered a multi-layered accommodation-entry arrangement involving entities with common KYC details. It argued that the lenders had negligible balances before receiving funds and that the immediate credit and debit movements raised doubts about their creditworthiness and the genuineness of the transactions.

    On examining the documentary evidence, the Tribunal found that the company had established the identity of the lenders, the genuineness of the transactions and their financial particulars. It noted that the AO had not brought any independent material on record to disprove the documents furnished by the company. The AO had also not issued summons to the lenders to verify their confirmations and financial statements.

    It noted that the third-party statement relied upon by the AO had not been furnished to the company and that no opportunity for cross-examination had been granted. Therefore, it deleted the addition of Rs. 3.60 crore under Section 68.

    On the addition towards estimated gross profit, the Bench noted that the company had explained that its bank credits included loan receipts and repayments, redemption of mutual fund investments, maturity proceeds of fixed deposits, and inter-bank and internal fund transfers. It observed:

    “Gross bank deposits or credits cannot, merely on that account, be treated as business turnover of an assessee. Bank accounts may contain various types of transactions, including capital receipts, loan receipts and repayments, inter-bank transfers, internal fund transfers and redemption or maturity proceeds of investments.”

    The Tribunal also found that the Revenue had not produced any specific material to establish that the remaining bank credits of Rs. 25.04 crore represented undisclosed sales or commercial services. It held that estimation of profit necessarily presupposes an underlying business activity and cannot be based merely on aggregate banking transactions.

    Distinguishing the Supreme Court's decision in Kachwala Gems v. JCIT, it noted that the case involved a taxpayer admittedly carrying on an active trading business, whereas no corresponding undisclosed trading or commercial activity had been established in the present case.

    Therefore, the Bench deleted the addition of Rs. 1.25 crore made by estimating gross profit at 5%. As both substantive additions had been deleted, it held that the company's grounds challenging the reopening of assessment, rejection of books of account and validity of the statutory approval had become academic. It dismissed these grounds as infructuous.

    Accordingly, the ITAT allowed the company's appeal.

    Counsel for Assessee: Rakesh Joshi

    Counsel for Revenue: Sujatha Iyyanger, Senior Departmental Representative

    Case Title :  Eva Sporting Aspirations Private Limited v. Income Tax OfficerCase Number :  ITA No. 3526/Mum/2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz ITAT(MUM) 319
    Next Story