NCLAT New Delhi Upholds Tycoons Industries Insolvency, Rejects Third-Party Liability Set-Off
Sandhra Suresh
18 Nov 2026 4:46 PM IST

The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), New Delhi, on 17 November dismissed an appeal filed by Joy Deb Chatterjee, former director of Tycoons Industries Private Limited, and upheld the admission of the company into the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) on a petition filed by Kokila Mining Private Limited under Section 9 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC).
A Bench of Officiating Chairperson Justice Yogesh Khanna with Technical Members Barun Mitra and Ajai Das Mehrotra held that liabilities allegedly owed by third-party entities cannot be adjusted against an operational debt to bring it below the statutory threshold for initiating insolvency proceedings. It said:
“We note the Appellant has failed to give any proof of pre-existing dispute. In the absence of any pre-existing dispute, clear acknowledgment of debt, as also the debt being reflected in the records of NeSL, the Ld. NCLT has rightly admitted the Corporate Debtor into CIRP under Section 9 of the IBC, 2016.”
Kokila Mining, the Operational Creditor, supplied heavy mining equipment, including tippers and excavators, to Tycoons Industries for coal mining operations under work orders dated 10 August 2022 and 1 July 2023.
Tycoons Industries admittedly availed the services, and Kokila Mining raised periodic invoices for the equipment deployed at its mining sites. The invoices aggregated Rs. 18.53 crore, against which payments and adjustments totalling Rs. 7.51 crore were made.
On 1 April 2024, the parties prepared a reconciliation statement-cum-balance confirmation, which a director of Tycoons Industries signed. The statement acknowledged the outstanding dues payable to Kokila Mining as on 31 March 2024.
Following continued non-payment, Kokila Mining issued a demand notice. Although Tycoons Industries subsequently paid Rs. 30 lakh, Kokila Mining claimed that more than Rs. 10.72 crore remained outstanding. The NCLT admitted its Section 9 petition, prompting the present appeal.
Challenging the admission order, Chatterjee argued that amounts allegedly payable by entities claimed to be sister concerns of Kokila Mining should have been adjusted against the outstanding debt, bringing it below the statutory threshold.
He also alleged the existence of pre-existing disputes and questioned the validity of the demand notice on the ground that Kokila Mining had served it at the corporate office instead of the registered office.
Kokila Mining submitted that it had dispatched the demand notice to both the registered office and the corporate office of Tycoons Industries. It denied that the entities relied upon by the appellant were its sister concerns and produced corporate records showing that they had no common shareholding or directorship.
Further, it pointed out that Tycoons Industries had neither replied to the Section 8 demand notice nor produced evidence of any pre-existing dispute.
The NCLAT held that service of a demand notice at either the corporate office or the registered office constituted valid service under the IBC.
It observed that the contractual relationship between the parties and the services provided by Kokila Mining were undisputed. It noted that the reconciliation statement expressly acknowledged outstanding dues exceeding Rs. 10 crore and certified that the account had been checked and verified.
The subsequent payment of Rs. 30 lakh further established the acknowledgement of liability, the Bench observed. It also noted that the debt appeared in the National E-Governance Services Limited (NeSL) records and had attained the status of “deemed authenticated” because Tycoons Industries had not raised any dispute before NeSL.
Rejecting the plea of pre-existing disputes, it held that Tycoons Industries had failed to produce any evidence substantiating its claim. It also found no evidence to establish that the entities whose liabilities the appellant sought to adjust were sister concerns of Kokila Mining.
Accordingly, the NCLAT upheld the NCLT's order admitting Tycoons Industries into CIRP and dismissed the appeal.
For Appellants: Senior Advocate Ankit Jain with Advocates Bharat Arora, Gaurav Arora, Himangi Arora
For Respondents: Advocate Anjani Sinha for R1; Advocates Vishal Ganda, Rashi Agarwal, Katyayni Singh for R2
