Interim Attachment In Civil Suit Cannot Defeat Pre-Existing Registered Mortgage Rights: Madras High Court

  • Interim Attachment In Civil Suit Cannot Defeat Pre-Existing Registered Mortgage Rights: Madras High Court

    The Madras High Court, Madurai Bench, has held that an interim attachment order in a pending civil suit cannot extinguish a pre-existing right created through a registered document.

    The court set aside a Sub-Registrar's refusal to register a settlement deed concerning a property purchased by an auction purchaser under the SARFAESI Act.

    Justice K. Kumaresh Babu observed that an interim attachment cannot take away a right that already existed before the attachment was ordered.

    “Even though the contention of learned Counsel for the petitioner that there would be priority of right of a mortgaged property in view of Section 26E of the SARFAESI Act, as interpreted by the Hon'ble Division Benches of this Court in the judgments relied upon by the petitioner, referred supra, it is further to be noted that an interim attachment in a pending civil suit will also not extinguish a pre-existing right created by a registered document. This is explicit from the provision of Section 64(2) of CPC r/w Order 38 Rule 10 CPC.” the court observed.

    The property was originally owned by a person who had mortgaged it with Indian Bank through a memorandum of deposit of title deeds. After the loan account was classified as a non-performing asset, the bank initiated proceedings under the SARFAESI Act and brought the secured property to auction.

    The petitioner purchased the property in the auction and was issued a sale certificate. He subsequently sought to execute a settlement deed in favour of his son.

    However, the Sub-Registrar refused to register the document on the ground that the property was subject to an attachment in a civil suit.

    Challenging the refusal, the auction purchaser argued that the bank's mortgage carried priority under Section 26E of the SARFAESI Act. He relied on earlier Division Bench decisions of the Madras High Court recognising the priority of rights arising from mortgages.

    A person who had advanced money to the original owner under a promissory note opposed the petition. He submitted that he had instituted a suit to recover the amount and obtained a decree. An interim attachment had also been ordered over the property during the pendency of the suit.

    He further pointed out that two cents of land had subsequently been sold to a third party in execution of the decree towards full satisfaction of the decretal amount. According to him, the third-party purchaser should also have been impleaded in the writ petition.

    The Government counsel also opposed the petition, arguing that the auction purchaser should not be permitted to execute the settlement deed, as it could lead to multiplicity of proceedings.

    The court noted that the mortgage in favour of Indian Bank was supported by deposits of title deeds made on various dates between 2009 and 2017. This had created a pre-existing right in favour of the bank.

    Referring to Section 64(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure read with Order 38 Rule 10 CPC, the court held that the subsequent attachment in the civil suit could not extinguish the bank's earlier rights. It also relied on Section 26E of the SARFAESI Act while recognising the bank's priority.

    “Hence, this Court is of the view that the third respondent Bank, which had a pre-existing right by way of memorandum of deposit of title deeds in support of its mortgage, read with Section 26E of the SARFAESI Act, has priority. It is therefore discernible that the order of attachment relied upon by the second respondent for issuing the impugned refusal check slip is wholly erroneous,” the judge observed.

    The court also rejected the argument that the sale of two cents of land in execution of the decree could affect the bank's pre-existing rights.

    “...when the suit had been decreed ex parte and an execution petition had also been terminated, the sale of a portion of the property cannot whittle out the pre-existing right with the third respondent in view of the discussion supra,” the court furthe opined.

    The court further examined the circumstances in which the promissory-note suit had been instituted. It noted that the promissory note was executed on July 1, 2018, while the suit was filed on August 13, 2018, just 43 days later. The original owner had remained ex parte in the proceedings.

    Taking note of these circumstances, the court observed:

    “Further, it is also to be noted that the suit had been filed within a period of 43 days from the date of execution of the promissory note and the conduct of the fourth respondent remaining ex parte would only drive this Court to the conclusion that the suit was filed in a collusive manner only to defeat the rights of the third respondent.”

    The court added that the third-party purchaser could work out their remedies against the original owner and the person who had instituted the promissory-note suit. It further observed that the sale in the execution proceedings had taken place pursuant to the collusive suit instituted by the person who had advanced money to the original owner.

    Allowing the writ petition, the court set aside the refusal check slip dated June 2, 2026.

    It directed the auction purchaser to re-present the settlement deed. The Sub-Registrar was directed to proceed with its registration if the document was otherwise in order.

    For Petitioner: Advocate I. Abrar Mohamed Abdullah

    For Respondents 1 & 2: Advocate S. Venkatesh, Additional Government Pleader

    For Respondent 3 (Indian Bank): C. Karthik

    For Respondent 5: Mr. A. Balakrishnan

    Case Title :  T. Kuthalingam v. The District Registrar & OthersCase Number :  W.P. (MD) No. 19335 of 2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (MAD) 370
    Next Story