Uncorroborated Survey Findings Cannot Prove GST Evasion: GSTAT Prayagraj

  • Uncorroborated Survey Findings Cannot Prove GST Evasion: GSTAT Prayagraj

    The GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Prayagraj Bench, has set aside a GST demand of ₹3.10 lakh against a book seller, holding that sales of around ₹70,000 recorded during a single-day survey could not, without corroboration, establish suppressed turnover over nine months.

    “A survey gathers information, and its findings must be corroborated before they are treated as proof of unreported turnover,” the tribunal observed.

    The bench comprising Judicial Member Mahtab Ahmad and Technical Member Ashish Varma was hearing an appeal filed by Grace Book Centre, a partnership firm trading in books, notebooks and stationery in Prayagraj.

    The department raised the demand following a survey at the firm's premises on March 31, 2018. It relied on sales of around ₹70,000 recorded up to the time of the survey, an unverified stock list and cash memos bearing an old VAT TIN. Based on these findings, it estimated monthly turnover of ₹1.67 lakh for the period from July 2017 to March 2018 and initiated proceedings under Section 74 of the GST Act.

    The tribunal found that the show-cause notice did not disclose facts establishing fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts with intent to evade tax. It noted that the survey was conducted on the last day of the financial year, just before the academic session, when textbook sales were seasonally at their highest. The department had neither reconciled the stock with the firm's books nor alleged any shortage, excess or unrecorded purchases.

    The tribunal observed that the survey note, as it read it, recorded that sales were made through manual bills and entered later into the firm's accounting software. The notice's assertion that no invoices had been issued was therefore not borne out by the survey record.

    The cash memos bearing the old VAT TIN recorded stationery sales of ₹16,909. The department had not established that these sales were omitted from the books or returns.

    “Non-participation may entitle the officer to decide on the material before him; it does not supply a finding that tax was withheld with intent to evade,” the tribunal observed.

    The tribunal also found that the assessing officer had adopted the estimated monthly figures without examining the returns available on the department's portal or explaining the calculation. The first appellate authority, in turn, failed to address the firm's grounds concerning its returns, exempt printed books and the quantification of the demand.

    “An appeal may be decided on the record in the appellant's absence; the grounds must still be examined and reasons given,” the tribunal held.

    Declining to remand the matter, the bench held that the defects in the notice and the demand's calculation could not be cured through a fresh hearing.

    It allowed the appeal, set aside the original and appellate orders, dropped the tax, interest and penalty demand of ₹3,10,289.76, and directed withdrawal of recovery proceedings. It also ordered a refund, with interest, of the pre-deposits to the extent actually paid and not already refunded.

    For Appellant: Advocates Arun Kumar Kushwaha and Anurag Singh

    For Revenue: Advocates Vibha Mishra, DC/SR, and Suneel Kumar Nirmal, AC/ASR,

    Case Title :  M/s Grace Book Centre v. Commissioner Concerned Uttar Pradesh Lucknow & Ors.Case Number :  APL/80/ALB/2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz GSTAT(ALB) 92
    Next Story