Mere Part B E-Way Bill Update Failure Cannot Attract Penalty Without Tax Evasion Intent: GSTAT Agra
Rajnandini Dutta
20 Nov 2026 3:25 PM IST

The Agra Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) on 19 November held that failure to update Part B of an e-way bill, without evidence of an intention to evade tax, cannot by itself attract a penalty under Section 129(3) of the GST Act.
A Bench comprising Judicial Member Ajeet Singh and Technical Member Vivek Kumar dismissed the Uttar Pradesh Tax Department's appeal against the order of the First Appellate Authority cancelling a penalty imposed on Tempsens Instruments India Limited for failing to update vehicle details in an e-way bill. The Tribunal observed:
“In the light of the foregoing discussion, the presumption of “Intention to evade Tax” is rebutted by the genuine documents accompanying the goods in this case. Hence in our opinion, the decision of the first appellate authority to quash the penalty order is entirely justified and supported by the facts of the case.”
The case concerned goods transported by Tempsens Instruments India Limited from Rajasthan to West Bengal. During transit through Uttar Pradesh, GST authorities intercepted the vehicle and found that the company had not updated Part B of one of the four e-way bills.
Although the goods were accompanied by tax invoices and other documents, the authorities treated the omission as a violation of the GST Rules and imposed a penalty under Section 129(3).
The company challenged the penalty before the First Appellate Authority, which set it aside. The Department subsequently challenged this decision before the Tribunal. The Department argued that Rule 138 of the GST Rules made it mandatory to fill Part B of an e-way bill and that failure to furnish vehicle details could not be treated as a minor technical lapse.
Tempsens Instruments India Limited submitted that the transaction was genuine, the invoices had already been generated on the GST portal, and the Department had not alleged any intention to evade tax.
The Tribunal noted that the Department had failed to establish any intention to evade tax and had based the penalty solely on non-compliance with the e-way bill requirements. It observed that genuine documents accompanying the goods and transaction details available on the GST portal rebutted the presumption of tax evasion.
Referring to the Allahabad High Court's decisions in Satyam Traders v. State of U.P. and Hindustan Herbal Cosmetics v. State of U.P., it reiterated that an intention to evade tax is necessary to impose a penalty under Section 129.
Further, the Bench noted that Uttar Pradesh was merely a transit state, as the goods were moving from Rajasthan to West Bengal.
Relying on the Allahabad High Court's decision in Maruti Enterprises v. State of U.P., it observed that a state through which goods merely pass has limited powers of inspection and verification and cannot exercise penal jurisdiction under Section 129 when no tax liability arises within that state.
Accordingly, the GSTAT upheld the First Appellate Authority's order cancelling the penalty and dismissed the Department's appeal.
For the Revenue: Mukesh Kumar, Authorised Representative.
For the taxpayer: Advocate Utkarsh Singhal.
