GST SCN Need Not Mention 'Fraud, Wilful Misstatement, Or Suppression' If Allegations Establish It: GSTAT Prayagraj
Rajnandini Dutta
17 Nov 2026 4:09 PM IST

The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Prayagraj Bench, has ruled that a show-cause notice need not expressly use the words "fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax" to invoke the extended tax-demand provision. The allegations and findings recorded in the notice and the original order must, however, establish the ingredients required by law.
A coram comprising Judicial Member Mahtab Ahmad and Technical Member Ashish Varma ruled,
"In our considered view, although the specific expression 'by reason of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax' has not been used in the notice and the order, the facts and conclusions recorded therein, in their pith and substance, satisfy the ingredients of Section 74 of the Act."
The tribunal was hearing an appeal filed by Fatehpur Foundry & Engineering Works. The dispute concerned Input Tax Credit (ITC) claimed on purchases from Ganesh Enterprises.
The tax authorities found the supplier to be non-existent during a spot inspection in 2022. The transactions had taken place in June 2018, nearly four years earlier. The authorities alleged that the purchases were fictitious and that the appellant had claimed ITC on the basis of bogus invoices.
The appellant maintained that the purchases were genuine. It relied on tax invoices, e-way bills, GST returns, books of accounts and payments made through banking channels.
It also pointed out that the supplier was registered and filing returns when the transactions took place. The supplier's registration was cancelled on November 10, 2020, on its own application.
The tribunal examined two Goods Receipts (GRs) issued by transporter Ajanta Carriers. It also examined two Dharm Kata slips issued by Natraaj Electronic Dharmkanta. The appellant had produced these documents for the first time before the tribunal.
The tribunal found several discrepancies in the GRs. One was a consignor's copy, although the appellant was the consignee in both transactions. The tribunal observed that both documents should therefore have been consignee's copies.
It also found that the last digit in the number of the second GR appeared to have been altered from '0' to '8'. The first GR did not mention a truck number. Entries relating to the description, weight and rate of goods also appeared to have been altered after erasing the original writing. The columns mentioning the vehicle owner and driver were blank in both GRs.
The tribunal found that the GRs were not genuine documents evidencing the movement of goods. It observed that they appeared to have been created or procured at the appellate stage to fill gaps in the appellant's case.
The Dharm Kata slips could, at best, evidence that the goods had been weighed at the destination. However, the tribunal held that their evidentiary value was undermined by the doubts surrounding the GRs. Their production for the first time during the appeal also raised questions about their genuineness.
The appellant had also produced invoices, e-way bills, books of accounts, and GST returns. The records showed that the supplier had reported the transactions in its returns and discharged its tax liability.
However, the tribunal found that these documents did not establish actual movement and delivery of the goods. In view of the fabricated GRs, it concluded that the documentation relating to the transactions was merely showpiece paperwork intended to enable the appellant to claim false ITC.
Holding that the appellant had not established actual receipt of the goods, the tribunal ruled that it was not entitled to avail and utilise ITC in respect of the transactions.
The tribunal distinguished the Allahabad High Court's decisions in Khurja Scrap Trading Company, Singhal Iron Traders and Saniya Traders. It noted that, unlike those cases, the present matter involved fabricated transport documents and evidence supporting the allegation of collusion with the supplier.
On the validity of the proceedings under Section 74 of the GST Act, the tribunal noted that the show-cause notice and the Order-in-Original had not expressly used the words "fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax".
However, the notice alleged that the supplier was non-existent and bogus. It further alleged that the appellant had availed and utilised ITC on the basis of showpiece invoices issued by the supplier, in collusion with it, and with the intention of evading tax. The Proper Officer also concluded that the appellant had failed to establish actual receipt of the goods.
The tribunal held that these facts and conclusions, read in substance, satisfied the ingredients of Section 74. It therefore found no infirmity in the notice or the original order.
The tribunal also relied on Section 160 of the GST Act. The provision protects notices and proceedings from being invalidated merely because of a mistake, defect, or omission. This protection applies where they are, in substance and effect, in conformity with the intent, purpose, and requirements of the Act.
The tribunal accordingly dismissed the appeal. It confirmed the Order-in-Appeal dated January 30, 2024, and the Order-in-Original dated June 2, 2023.
For Appellant: Advocates Satyarth Agrawal, Sanjeev Agrawal and Deepika Bedi Agrawal -
For Revenue: Vibha Mishra, DCST, assisted by Suneel Kumar Nirmal, ACST,
