Difference In Book Value And Purchase Cost Of Unsold Stock Cannot Attract GST: GSTAT Prayagraj

  • Difference In Book Value And Purchase Cost Of Unsold Stock Cannot Attract GST: GSTAT Prayagraj

    On Thursday, 19 November, the Prayagraj Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) held that a difference between the book value and purchase cost of unsold stock cannot be treated as suppressed sales for levying GST, as tax liability arises only upon an actual supply of goods.

    A Division Bench of Judicial Member Mahtab Ahmad and Technical Member Ashish Varma also held that goods physically available at a dealer's premises cannot be treated as sold merely because the books of account reflect a different valuation. The Tribunal observed:

    “A difference between two valuations of the same stock is a difference in valuation, and it is not a sale. The FAA's own method shows this, because it values the goods at cost with no profit added, which is how stock is valued and not how a selling price is fixed.”

    Raj Trading Company, a dealer in iron and steel goods, challenged a GST demand arising from discrepancies that the Department found during an inspection of its sales records and stock accounts.

    The First Appellate Authority treated the difference between the recorded closing stock value and the value calculated at the average purchase price as suppressed sales and imposed GST. The dealer challenged this finding before the Tribunal, contending that a difference in stock valuation did not establish any actual sale.

    The Tribunal found that the disputed goods were physically available at the dealer's premises. The Department had also failed to identify any sale, buyer, price or date of supply to establish that the goods had been sold.

    It held that Section 35(6) of the GST Act, which deals with unaccounted goods, could not be invoked merely because the value of unsold stock differed in the books of account.

    Further, the Bench held that the First Appellate Authority had introduced a new ground for demanding tax that did not form part of the original show cause notice. This violated Section 75(7) of the GST Act, which prohibits confirmation of a demand on grounds not specified in the notice.

    However, it upheld the demand relating to unreported sales established through seized records and an unexplained shortage of stock. It found that the dealer had failed to disclose these supplies in its GST returns, amounting to suppression under Section 74 of the GST Act.

    Accordingly, the GSTAT partly allowed the appeal, deleted the demand arising from the revaluation of unsold stock and reduced the confirmed GST liability from Rs. 13,97,074 to Rs. 3,47,826, with consequential modifications to penalty and interest.

    For the Appellant: Advocates Arun Kumar Kushwaha and Anurag Singh

    For the Department: Deputy Commissioner Vibha Mishra and Assistant Commissioner Suneel Kumar Nirmal

    Case Title :  Raj Trading Company v. Commissioner Concerned Uttar Pradesh & Ors.Case Number :  APL/74/ALB/2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz GSTAT(ALB) 96
    Next Story