70:30 GST Formula For Solar Power Contracts Optional For Pre-2019 Supplies: Supreme Court

  • 70:30 GST Formula For Solar Power Contracts Optional For Pre-2019 Supplies: Supreme Court

    The Supreme Court has held that the 70:30 formula for valuing goods and services supplied under solar power generating system contracts cannot be compulsorily applied to transactions made before January 1, 2019. Taxpayers could choose to adopt the formula for the earlier period, but tax authorities could not impose it on those who had not exercised that option.

    A bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva allowed an appeal filed by Sterling and Wilson Pvt. Ltd., setting aside a tax demand raised by the GST authorities.

    “Thus, it is pristinely clear that only an option was given to assessees who wanted to take recourse to the new scheme, that came into effect from 01.01.2019, even for the period prior thereto if they so chose. There was no mandate, either in the Notification or in the Circular, that the 70:30 ratio had to be compulsorily applied to all the past transactions prior to 01.01.2019, irrespective of whether or not the assessee concerned chose to adopt it. Therefore, the notion of the authorities that the option given to the assessees, whereby they could adopt the 70:30 ratio even for supplies made prior to 01.01.2019, should be mandatorily applied across the board even to assessees who did not choose that option, is patently erroneous and wholly unsustainable,” the court observed.

    The court made this observation while examining whether Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST, which allowed taxpayers to adopt the 70:30 formula for pre-2019 supplies, made its application compulsor

    The judgment, authored by Justice Sanjay Kumar, also held that solar power generating systems do not become immovable property merely because they are fixed to civil foundations. It further rejected the invocation of extended limitation under Section 74 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017.

    Sterling and Wilson undertakes turnkey Engineering, Procurement and Construction (EPC) contracts involving the supply and installation of solar power generating systems. The company paid GST at 5% on supplies made between July 2017 and December 2018.

    The tax authorities subsequently applied the 70:30 formula, treated the transactions as works contracts and demanded additional tax and penalties. They alleged that the company had wilfully misstated and suppressed facts. Sterling and Wilson approached the Supreme Court after the Bombay High Court dismissed its writ petition on the ground that a statutory appeal was available.

    Notification No. 24/2018-Central Tax (Rate), which introduced the 70:30 formula, came into force on January 1, 2019. Under this mechanism, 70% of the total contract value is treated as the value of goods, while the remaining 30% is treated as the value of specified services. The goods component is taxed at 5% and the services component at 18%.

    Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST subsequently clarified that taxpayers could adopt this formula for supplies made between July 1, 2017 and December 31, 2018. However, it ruled out refunds where the tax already paid exceeded the amount calculated under this mechanism.

    The court noted that the circular used the word "can," indicating that taxpayers had a choice. The authorities had wrongly treated this permission as compulsory. It also clarified that instructions issued by the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs under Section 168 of the CGST Act bind officers implementing the legislation.

    The court further noted that a subsequent notification issued in 2021 replaced the earlier tariff entry referring to a “solar power generating system” with one referring only to a “solar power generator”. It observed that the earlier entry treated the entire solar power generating system as a single unit for taxation. The change could not be applied retrospectively to earlier transactions.

    "In any event, the aforestated clarification indicated in positive terms that an option was given to assessees to adopt the same mechanism that was introduced with effect from 01.01.2019 for the period prior thereto also. This is manifest from the fact that the clarification stated that GST on such renewable energy projects 'can' be paid in terms of 70:30 ratio for goods and services for the period 01.07.2017 to 31.12.2018 also, indicating that the choice was with the assessees. This being the position, it appears that the CGST authorities misunderstood this clarification to imply a mandate that even for the period prior to 01.01.2019, all assessees were bound to implement the 70:30 ratio for payment of tax", it noted.

    The court rejected the authorities' argument that including civil works in the EPC contracts automatically made the transactions works contracts. The solar panels and modules could be detached from the civil foundations and used elsewhere. The foundations merely provided stability to the systems.

    “The fact that a SPG system has to be fixed on a civil foundation for stability and to ensure proper functioning would not, by itself, convert it into immovable property,” the court held.

    The court discussed earlier decisions, including Solid and Correct Engineering Works, Sirpur Paper Mills, Duncans Industries and Bharti Airtel, on determining whether equipment attached to the earth constitutes movable or immovable property. The relevant considerations include the nature and purpose of attachment, intention of permanence, functionality, removability and marketability.

    The court also held that there was no basis to allege fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression for not applying a tax mechanism that came into force only in January 2019. The invocation of extended limitation under Section 74 was therefore unsustainable.

    Allowing the appeal, the Supreme Court set aside the adjudication order dated January 17, 2025, and the consequential summary order dated January 24, 2025, demanding taxes and penalties. The parties were directed to bear their own costs.

    For Appellants: Senior Advocate Arvind P. Datar, Senior Advocate Prakash Shah, Advocates Mihir Mehta, Vishnu Kant (AOR), Rajnandini, Sarthak Singh, Ratnesh Kumar and Shikha Bharti.

    For Respondents: Additional Solicitor General N. Venkataraman, Advocates Karan Lahiri, Gurmeet Singh Makker (AOR), Aaditya Dixit, Digvijay Dam and Raman Yadav.

    Case Title :  M/s. Sterling and Wilson Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India and othersCase Number :  SLP (C) No. 23844 of 2025CITATION :  2026 LLBiz SC 353
    Next Story