GST | Not Replying To Show Cause Notice Does Not Take Away Taxpayer's Right To Personal Hearing: Allahabad High Court
Upasna Agrawal
16 Nov 2026 11:11 AM IST

The Allahabad High Court has held that a taxpayer who does not reply to a show cause notice does not thereby forfeit the opportunity of personal hearing and that the adjudicating authority is still bound to fix the date, time and venue of the hearing.
Justice Vikas Budhwar held
“As a matter of fact once a show cause notice is issued then it is for the Assessee either to reply or not and further even in fact in case no reply has been submitted and a column has been earmarked in the show cause notice fixing the date, time and the venue of hearing, then proprietary demanded that the authority in original ought to have fixed date time and venue of personal hearing so as to enable the Assessee to put forward his stand orally though as per the claim set up by the respondents, the reply was not submitted.”
Petitioner is a partnership firm at Saharanpur engaged in transport of goods by road. The dispute relates to the financial year 2018-19. On July 15, 2023 a notice under Section 61 of the Act was issued over discrepancies in the returns, to which, according to the department, no reply was filed and no adjournment sought. A show cause notice in Form GST DRC-01 followed on December 23, 2023, fixing January 23, 2024 as the date for filing reply. Against the columns for the date, time and venue of personal hearing, the notice recited “N.A.”
An order under Section 73 of the Act was passed on April 23, 2024, by the Assistant Commissioner, State Tax, Saharanpur, and the appeal under Section 107 was rejected on August 04, 2025 on the ground of a delay of 70 days. Both orders were challenged before the High Court.
Petitioner argued that the original authority was bound to fix the date, time and venue of personal hearing and had not done so, and that the appellate order could not stand once the original order was vitiated at its foundation. Standing Counsel submitted that what mattered was the conduct of the assessee, which had replied to neither notice, but could not dispute that no personal hearing had been fixed.
Holding that the proceedings were vitiated, the Court observed
“Since the very foundation itself is weak eliminating the substratum, thus the entire proceeding stands vitiated.”
Since the show cause notice had been annexed to the writ petition, the Court held the petitioner to be deemed to have full knowledge of it, and directed that the proceedings be taken up from the stage following service of the notice.
Setting aside both orders and remitting the matter to the Assistant Commissioner, the Court directed the petitioner to file its reply by November 13, 2026 and the authority to hear it in the week commencing November 23, 2026 after at least five days' prior intimation, and to pass an order by December 24, 2026. Adjournments were to be granted only in exceptional circumstances beyond the control of the assessee, and not beyond three days at a stretch.
