Unaccounted Stock Cannot Be Confiscated Without First Determining Tax Liability: GSTAT Agra
Arvind Kumar Tiwari
20 Nov 2026 3:05 PM IST

The Agra Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), on 19 November, held that the discovery of unaccounted stock during an inspection does not, by itself, permit the Department to initiate confiscation proceedings under Section 130 of the GST Act. The proper officer must instead determine the tax liability under Sections 73 or 74.
A Bench comprising Judicial Member Ajeet Singh and Technical Member Vivek Kumar dismissed the Uttar Pradesh Tax Department's appeal against the order setting aside the penalty and fine of Rs. 1,45,055 imposed on Kamlesh Trading Company for possessing 15,441 kg of unaccounted tobacco stem powder. It observed:
“the proper officer is empowered to determine the amount of tax payable on the goods or the services which are unaccounted for as if such goods or services had been supplied by such person and the provisions of section 73 or 74 shall mutates mutandis apply for determination of the said tax.”
The dispute arose from an inspection conducted by the Special Investigation Branch, Etawah, at Kamlesh Trading Company's business premises on 30 November 2024. During verification of its records and stock, officers found 15,441 kg of unaccounted tobacco stem powder and seized the stock. They subsequently issued a show-cause notice proposing confiscation and penalty.
The proper officer rejected the company's reply and, through an order dated 17 March 2025, determined the value of the unaccounted goods at Rs. 3,39,442 and imposed a penalty and fine aggregating to Rs. 1,45,055.
Kamlesh Trading Company challenged the order before the First Appellate Authority, which set aside the penalty and fine. The State Tax Department then approached the GSTAT, arguing that officers empowered to inspect business premises and verify records were also authorised to initiate confiscation proceedings.
The Tribunal examined the statutory provisions governing the maintenance of accounts by registered persons. It noted that the law provides a specific mechanism for determining tax liability where a taxpayer fails to maintain proper accounts of goods or services. Under this mechanism, unaccounted goods are treated as though they had been supplied by the taxpayer, and the tax payable is determined under Sections 73 or 74.
Further, it held that the proper officer could not directly initiate confiscation proceedings merely because an inspection revealed excess or unaccounted stock. Instead, the officer had to initiate proceedings under Sections 73 or 74 to determine the tax payable. It added:
“where at the time of survey of business premises excess or unaccounted goods are found, the proper officer is only empowered to initiate proceedings u/s 73/74 of CGST/UPGST, Act, against business entity concerned, he is not authorised by law to initiate proceedings u/s 130 and levy the penalty and fine in lieu of confiscation of goods.”
Applying this interpretation, the Bench found that the proper officer had initiated confiscation proceedings without following the prescribed procedure for determining tax liability on the unaccounted stock. It held that the First Appellate Authority had correctly set aside the penalty and fine.
Accordingly, the GSTAT dismissed the Department's appeal.
Counsel for Appellant: Mukesh Kumar
Counsel for Respondent: Saurabh Agrawal
