GSTAT Finds Works Contractor Kept Royalty Out Of GST Returns To Evade Tax, Confirms ₹1 Crore Demand

  • GSTAT Finds Works Contractor Kept Royalty Out Of GST Returns To Evade Tax, Confirms ₹1 Crore Demand

    The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Bengaluru, has held that a works contractor deliberately kept royalty deductions out of its GST returns to evade tax payable under the reverse charge mechanism.

    Finding that the contractor knew of the tax liability but did not disclose the transactions, the tribunal held that the extended limitation under Section 74 of the CGST Act applied.

    A bench of Judicial Member Prabhakaran P.M. and Technical Member (State) Ravi Jesuraj S. allowed the Revenue's appeal and confirmed a tax demand of ₹1,00,20,488, along with interest and an equal penalty.

    The case concerned PRN Infratech, a Hubballi-based firm executing works contracts for government departments. Between July 2017 and October 2019, the departments deducted ₹8.86 crore as royalty on minor minerals from its bills. The firm recorded the deductions in its books but did not declare the amounts in its GSTR-3B returns from July 2017 to September 2019.

    After the Department initiated an inquiry in September 2019, the firm paid ₹46.37 lakh towards GST on royalty for April to October 2019. It paid no interest and left the tax for the earlier period unpaid.

    The firm's General Manager (Accounts), responsible for GST returns and payments, admitted in a statement that licensing services for the right to use minerals were taxable under reverse charge. He disputed that the firm was the recipient because it held no mining licence. The tribunal noted that the statement was never retracted or challenged.

    The firm argued that the deductions were reflected in government bills and its books, and that it believed the liability rested with mining leaseholders. It also claimed that the matter was revenue neutral because it could claim input tax credit.

    Rejecting these arguments, the tribunal held that disclosure to the works departments did not amount to disclosure to the proper GST officer. It also noted that Section 17(5)(i), as it then stood, barred input tax credit for tax paid under Section 74.

    The tribunal observed, “Each circumstance, taken alone, may not be enough. Taken together, they lead to one reasonable conclusion: the Respondent kept the royalty out of its returns so that the tax on it would not be paid. That is suppression of facts to evade tax. The Revenue has discharged the burden that lay on it.”

    The tribunal set aside the appellate authority's decision to apply Section 73 instead of Section 74. It confirmed the ₹1,00,20,488 tax demand under Section 74, directed payment of interest under Section 50 and imposed an equal penalty under Section 74(9), read with Section 74(1). The ₹46.37 lakh already paid was appropriated against the tax demand.

    For Appellant: Venu Gopala Naidu

    For Respondent: Jatin Christopher

    Case Title :  The Commissioner of Central GST and Central Excise, Belagavi Commissionerate v. M/s PRN InfratechCase Number :  APL/42/BUR/2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz GSTAT(BLR) 97
    Next Story