GSTAT Delhi Dismisses Appeal Against ₹1.36 Lakh IGST Demand On Bangla Foods, Cites ₹20 Lakh Threshold
Arvind Kumar Tiwari
20 Nov 2026 4:57 PM IST

On Friday, 20 November, the Principal Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), New Delhi, dismissed the Department's appeal against the setting aside of a GST demand of Rs. 1.36 lakh on Bangla Foods Private Limited for alleged non-payment of IGST under the reverse charge mechanism on online advertising services received from Facebook Ireland Limited.
A Bench comprising Judicial Member Justice Mayank Kumar Jain and Technical Member A. Venu Prasad held that the appeal did not meet the Rs. 20 lakh monetary threshold prescribed under CBIC Circular No. 207/1/2024-GST. It also found that the Department had failed to establish that the dispute qualified for any exception under the circular. It said:
“Mere issuance of few show cause notices cannot, by itself, cannot establish that the issue is recurring in nature. Therefore, the contention of the Department remains unsupported by any cogent evidence.”
The dispute arose from an alert issued by the Directorate General of GST Intelligence (DGGI), alleging that Bangla Foods had failed to pay IGST of Rs. 1,36,634 under the reverse charge mechanism on Online Information and Database Access or Retrieval (OIDAR) services provided by Facebook Ireland Limited during FY 2017-18.
The Department issued a show-cause notice on 1 August 2024, proposing recovery of the tax along with interest and an equal penalty. The adjudicating authority confirmed the demand through an order dated 22 January 2025.
Bangla Foods challenged the demand before the First Appellate Authority, arguing that it had not received any services from Facebook Ireland Limited during the relevant period. It submitted its audited financial statements, profit and loss account and advertising expense ledger. These records showed advertising expenditure of Rs. 42,738 but contained no entry relating to Facebook Ireland Limited.
On 3 October 2025, the First Appellate Authority allowed the appeal and set aside the demand. It found that the adjudicating authority had relied on the DGGI alert without independently examining any concrete evidence that Bangla Foods had received the alleged services.
The Department challenged this decision before the GSTAT, arguing that Bangla Foods had received taxable OIDAR services and that the First Appellate Authority had failed to adequately verify the relevant financial records. It further argued that the dispute involved a recurring issue and interpretation of statutory provisions concerning reverse charge liability and place of supply. According to the Department, these issues brought the appeal within the exceptions under the CBIC circular.
Bangla Foods raised a preliminary objection to the maintainability of the appeal. It submitted that Circular No. 207/1/2024-GST prescribes a monetary threshold of Rs. 20 lakh for appeals before the GSTAT. It further argued that, in cases involving a tax demand, the Department must consider only the disputed tax amount, irrespective of the accompanying interest or penalty.
The Tribunal noted that the disputed tax amount was Rs. 1,36,634, significantly below the prescribed threshold. It also found that the Department had not produced copies of the alleged show-cause notices issued for other financial years or any orders to establish that the issue was recurring in nature.
Rejecting the Department's reliance on the exceptions under the circular, it held that the dispute essentially concerned whether Bangla Foods had received OIDAR services from Facebook Ireland Limited during the relevant period. It did not raise any substantial question concerning the interpretation of the relevant notification or determination of place of supply, as the Department had contended.
Further, the Bench criticised the Department's decision to file the appeal despite the monetary threshold, observing:
“In our opinion, by this act, the learned authority who recorded his satisfaction as to the legality or propriety of the impugned order directed to file an appeal before this tribunal has not only frustrated the very purpose of the National Litigation Policy and the spirit of the Circular but also wasted the judicial resources of this Tribunal.”
It also held that the Department had failed to establish that the appeal qualified for any exception under the circular. Since the disputed tax amount fell below the Rs. 20 lakh threshold, it held that the appeal was not maintainable.
Accordingly, the GSTAT dismissed the Department's appeal without examining whether Bangla Foods was liable to pay IGST under the reverse charge mechanism on the alleged online advertising services.
Counsel for Appellant: Subkaran Singh
Counsel for Respondent: Ashu Dalmia and Ankita Jha
