Exporters' KYC Documents Can't Be Rejected Merely Because Customs Broker Didn't Meet Them: Delhi High Court

  • Exporters KYC Documents Cant Be Rejected Merely Because Customs Broker Didnt Meet Them: Delhi High Court

    The Delhi High Court has held that a customs broker's Know Your Customer (KYC) documents cannot be rejected merely because the broker did not personally meet the exporter, particularly when the Customs Department has not alleged that the documents were forged.

    The division bench of Justices Avneesh Jhingan and Shail Jain upheld a CESTAT order setting aside the revocation of a customs broker's licence, forfeiture of security deposit and imposition of a ₹50,000 penalty over alleged violations of KYC requirements.

    The Court observed that the broker had complied with the prescribed KYC requirements by obtaining the exporters' PAN and Aadhaar cards.

    "These documents could not have been rejected merely on the ground that the respondent had failed to meet the exporter more so, when the department had not alleged that these documents were forged," the court noted while affirming the Tribunal's findings.

    The case arose after the Customs Department received an analytics report in May 2023 flagging alleged fraudulent exports by non-existent entities. The report named Mauli Worldwide Logistics, a customs broker, for alleged violations of Regulation 10(n) of the Customs Brokers Licensing Regulations, 2018.

    Following an inquiry, the Customs Commissioner revoked the broker's licence, forfeited its security deposit and imposed a penalty of ₹50,000, holding that the prescribed KYC requirements had not been fulfilled.

    However CESTAT set aside the order, prompting the Customs Department to approach the High Court.

    Before the High Court, the Department argued that the broker had failed to comply with Regulation 10(n) and that the Tribunal had erroneously relied on KYC documents allegedly produced for the first time before it.

    The High Court noted that the analytics report alleging exports by non-existent entities was not supported by any physical verification conducted by the authority preparing it.

    It further observed that the broker had claimed to have obtained the exporters' KYC documents and verified their Importer Exporter Code (IEC), PAN and GST registration details through the respective government websites.

    The Court noted that the inquiry officer had not rejected the broker's claim that PAN and Aadhaar cards, along with authorisations, had been submitted. Neither was there any finding that the documents were forged.

    Ir held that the Tribunal had rightly concluded that the broker complied with the applicable Customs Circular, which prescribed the documents required for KYC verification.

    Rejecting the Department's contention that the Tribunal had relied on documents produced for the first time in appeal, the Court observed that the Department's case itself was not established in the absence of any finding that the prescribed KYC documents were missing or forged.

    For Appellant: Advocates Aakarsh Srivastava, SSC with Dhananjay Parth

    For Respondent: Advocate Shikha Spra & Umang Srivastva

    Case Title :  Commissioner of Customs (Airport and General), New Delhi v. M/s Mauli Worldwide LogisticsCase Number :  CUSAA 89/2025CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (DEL) 1258
    Next Story