Centre Can Refuse Anti-Dumping Duty Despite DA's Recommendation On Public Interest Grounds: Delhi HC
Kapil Dhyani
17 Nov 2026 8:21 PM IST

The Delhi High Court has held that the Central Government is not bound to impose anti-dumping duty merely because the Designated Authority has recommended it and can refuse to impose such duty after considering broader public interest, including the impact on consumers and industries dependent on imported goods.
The Division Bench of Justices Anil Kshetarpal and Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar observed that the Centre's discretion under Section 9A(1) of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975, extends beyond protecting domestic manufacturers and includes balancing their interests against those of downstream industries and the consuming public.
"In declining to impose ADD despite a positive recommendation, the CG acts as custodian of the public interest at large and is required to balance the interests of the domestic industry against those of the downstream user industry and the consuming public," it observed.
The ruling came in a petition filed by Supreme Petrochem Limited challenging the Centre's decision not to impose anti-dumping duty on imports of polystyrene despite a positive recommendation by the Designated Authority.
Supreme Petrochem, a domestic manufacturer of polystyrene, had approached the Designated Authority along with other domestic producers seeking anti-dumping duty on imports originating in or exported from Iran, Malaysia, Singapore, Chinese Taipei, the UAE and the USA.
Following an investigation, the Designated Authority issued its final findings recommending anti-dumping duty on the goods. However, the Central Government decided not to impose the recommended duty.
Aggrieved, Supreme Petrochem approached the High Court challenging both the constitutional validity of the statutory provisions governing the Centre's discretion and its decision not to impose the duty.
Petitioner argued that the Centre could not disregard the Designated Authority's findings without sufficient justification, particularly when the recommendation followed a detailed investigation. It further contended that the Centre's refusal was based on concerns regarding domestic production capacity, which had already been examined by the Designated Authority.
The Centre however submitted that the imposition of anti-dumping duty was discretionary and that it was entitled to consider broader public interest. It argued that domestic production was inadequate to meet demand, particularly after one of the three domestic manufacturers ceased operations, and imposing the duty could adversely affect industries dependent on polystyrene.
The High Court observed that Section 9A(1) of the Customs Tariff Act uses the expression "may", indicating that the power to impose anti-dumping duty is discretionary rather than mandatory.
It held that the Designated Authority's role is confined to examining dumping, injury to domestic industry and the causal link between them, while the Centre retains the final decision-making authority.
The Court further observed that Article 9.1 of the WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement expressly permits importing countries to decide whether to impose anti-dumping duty even when the necessary conditions are satisfied.
Rejecting the petitioner's challenge, the Court held that the Centre's discretion was neither unguided nor arbitrary, as it was governed by considerations of public interest and the objective of maintaining fair trade without encouraging protectionism.
In the present case, the Court noted that one of the three domestic polystyrene manufacturers had ceased operations following a fire.
The centre had also obtained assessments from NITI Aayog and other government agencies concerning the likely impact of imposing anti-dumping duty on domestic supply and downstream industries.
The court observed that the Centre was entitled to consider whether reliance on the two remaining domestic producers, without competitively priced imports, would adequately meet the requirements of downstream industries.
It held that these considerations were distinct from the Designated Authority's examination of injury caused by dumped imports.
The Court further held that the Centre's decision not to impose anti-dumping duty was legislative or quasi-legislative in character and did not require a fresh oral hearing after the Designated Authority's investigation.
However, it clarified that such decisions remained subject to judicial review, including examination of whether they were based on relevant material and whether extraneous considerations or mala fides influenced them.
Finding that the Centre's decision was supported by material bearing a rational connection to public interest, the High Court declined to interfere.
For Petitioner: Senior Advocate Ramesh Singh along with Advocate Jitender Singh and Advocate Anshumaan Sahni.
For Respondents: CGSC Nidhi Raman along with SSC Anurag Ojha, Advocate Dipak Raj, Advocate Aryaman Singh Chouhan and Advocate Aditya Chaudhary.
