Leasehold Asset Alone Does Not Justify Restoration Of Struck-Off Company: NCLAT
Sandhra Suresh
21 Nov 2026 6:04 PM IST

The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) at Delhi has recently upheld the refusal to restore Radiant Inn Private Limited's name to the Register of Companies, holding that a subsisting leasehold interest alone does not justify restoration when the company has no intention of resuming business and seeks restoration only to realise the asset and close its affairs.
A bench of Judicial Member Justice Sharad Kumar Sharma and Technical Members Arun Baroka and Indevar Pandey observed:
“The existence of a subsisting leasehold interest, is not sufficient to warrant restoration, particularly when the Appellant does not propose to recommence business and seeks restoration only for realisation of the asset and closure of its affairs.”
The appeal arose from an order of the Mumbai bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), which rejected the company's restoration application. The Registrar of Companies had struck off its name through a notice in Form STK-7 dated September 12, 2018.
The company was incorporated as Chaitanya Institute of Medical Sciences Private Limited in February 2008 and changed its name in 2015. It claimed a 95-year leasehold interest in a 4,000-square-metre plot belonging to the Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation (MIDC) in Butibori, Nagpur.
However, it had not filed financial statements and annual returns after FY 2013-14 and had not applied for dormant-company status under Section 455 of the Companies Act, 2013.
During the appeal, the NCLAT asked whether the company intended to resume business after restoration. In an affidavit affirmed in July 2026, it clarified that it had no plans to recommence operations and sought restoration only to realise or transfer its leasehold rights, regularise statutory compliances and discharge liabilities.
The company argued that the Registrar had not served an individual notice in Form STK-1 under Section 248(1) and had failed to satisfy himself that sufficient provision had been made for realisation of amounts due to the company and discharge of its liabilities under Section 248(6).
It also argued that Section 252(3) provides alternative grounds for restoration, allowing a company to seek restoration even if it was not carrying on business, provided it was otherwise just to do so.
The NCLAT acknowledged that service of Form STK-1 had not been established. However, it held that this procedural lapse alone did not justify restoration. The company's financial statements showed no revenue from operations, while its bank statements reflected mostly transfers from directors and payments towards bank charges and utilities. The bench observed that electricity and water payments merely indicated upkeep of the property, not business activity.
The bench agreed that restoration could be justified even if a company was not carrying on business. However, owning an asset did not automatically satisfy the requirement that restoration be otherwise just.
It further observed, “Restoration under Section 252(3) places the company and other persons, as nearly as possible, in the position they would have occupied had its name not been struck off. It restores the company's corporate status; it is not merely a mechanism for enabling its former Directors to deal with a particular asset.”
The bench noted that no creditor, workman, statutory authority, or MIDC had sought restoration. While accepting that the leasehold interest subsisted, it clarified that it was expressing no opinion on its transferability, which would depend on the lease conditions and MIDC permissions.
The NCLAT dismissed the appeal and upheld the NCLT's order refusing restoration, clarifying that its decision would not affect the rights of MIDC or other stakeholders.
For Appellants: Advocates Anup Lohiya, Abhishek Aggarwal, Aayush Aggarwal and Chahat Aggarwal,
For Respondent: None (Registrar of Companies proceeded ex parte).
