Karnataka High Court Quashes Proceedings Against Maruti Suzuki Directors For Not Arraigning Company

  • Karnataka High Court Quashes Proceedings Against Maruti Suzuki Directors For Not Arraigning Company

    The Karnataka High Court on 13 November quashed criminal proceedings against ten directors of Maruti Suzuki India Limited over alleged violations of the Legal Metrology Act, 2009, after the Legal Metrology Department initiated prosecution without arraigning the company as an accused.

    Justice H.P. Sandesh held that a company must be arraigned as an accused before its directors can be prosecuted for offences allegedly committed by it. The Bench observed:

    “…in the absence of company being made as party to the proceedings and unless the company is arraigned as accused, the Directors cannot be held responsible and there cannot be any liability on the individuals, who are working as Directors and there must be specific pleading against them and without any pleading also, there cannot be any vicarious liability.”

    The case arose from an inspection conducted by the Legal Metrology Department at the premises of R.N.S. Motors Limited, a dealership of Maruti Suzuki. Following the inspection, the department issued a compounding notice under Section 48 of the Act to the dealership, identifying Maruti Suzuki as the manufacturer of the products in question.

    Maruti Suzuki disputed the alleged violations and requested the department to withdraw the notice. The department subsequently issued another compounding notice and a clarification-cum-compounding notice, reiterating the alleged violations.

    It then filed a complaint before the Magistrate, who took cognizance and issued summons to ten directors of Maruti Suzuki.

    The directors approached the High Court seeking to quash the criminal proceedings, contending that the department had not arraigned Maruti Suzuki as an accused, despite identifying it as the manufacturer in its notices.

    On the other hand, the department argued that the failure to arraign the company as an accused was a curable defect.

    The Court accepted the directors' contention, noting that the department had identified Maruti Suzuki as the manufacturer but had not made it an accused in the complaint.

    Relying on the Supreme Court's decision in Aneeta Hada v. Godfather Travels, it reiterated that prosecution of directors for offences committed by a company cannot be sustained without arraigning the company as an accused.

    Further, the Bench observed that directors cannot be held vicariously liable in the absence of specific pleadings against them.

    Accordingly, the High Court allowed the petitions and quashed the criminal proceedings against the directors, including the Magistrate's order taking cognizance and issuing summons.

    For Petitioners: Senior Advocate Uday Holla and Advocate Monica Patil

    For Respondent: Advocate Suhas Gowda M, HCGP

    Case Title :  Davinder Singh Brar and Ors v. State of KarnatakaCase Number :  Criminal Petition No. 1663 of 2021CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (KAR) 231
    Next Story