Changing Company Name Doesn't Give Fresh Cause Of Action To Challenge Existing Word: Delhi High Court

  • Changing Company Name Doesnt Give Fresh Cause Of Action To Challenge Existing Word: Delhi High Court

    The Delhi High Court on 18 November held that a change in a company's name does not give rise to a fresh cause of action to challenge the continued use of a disputed word when that word was already part of the company's earlier name.

    Justice Amit Mahajan dismissed a writ petition filed by Swedish security services company Securitas AB against Tapish Securitas Private Limited, seeking removal of the word 'SECURITAS' from the latter's name. The Bench observed:

    “…the words 'change of name' in Section 16(1)(b) give a fresh period of limitation only where the change introduces the name, or the part thereof, to which objection is taken.”

    Securitas AB, which claims to hold the registered trademark 'SECURITAS' in India since 2005, sought removal of the disputed word from Tapish Securitas' name.

    Tapish Securitas was incorporated in 2010 as Red Fox Securitas Private Limited. It changed its name to Tapish Securitas Private Limited in 2018, retaining the word 'SECURITAS'.

    In September 2019, Securitas AB approached the Regional Director, Ministry of Corporate Affairs, under Section 16(1)(b) of the Companies Act, 2013, seeking a direction to Tapish Securitas to delete the word 'SECURITAS' from its name. The Regional Director dismissed the application, holding that the claim was barred by limitation.

    Challenging the order, Securitas AB contended that Tapish Securitas' change of name in 2018 gave rise to a fresh cause of action to seek rectification. Tapish Securitas opposed the petition, arguing that the disputed word had been part of its name since 2010 and that the 2018 change merely replaced 'Red Fox' with 'Tapish'.

    The Court held that a company cannot revive an already time-barred claim by changing a different part of its name. Since 'SECURITAS' had been part of Tapish Securitas' name since 2010, the 2018 change did not give rise to a fresh cause of action for Securitas AB.

    It also rejected Securitas AB's reliance on Section 4(2) of the Companies Act and Rule 8A of the Companies (Incorporation) Rules, holding that these provisions operate at the stage of registration of a company's name and do not create a separate remedy, free from limitation, to challenge a name that has already been registered.

    Accordingly, the High Court dismissed the petition and imposed costs of Rs. 25,000 on Securitas AB.

    For Petitioner: Advocates Aditya Verma, Devyani Nath and Saumya Pandey

    For Respondents: Advocates Mukul Singh, CGSC, Aryan Dhaka, Priyal Goswami, Dr. Vikraant Narayan Vasudeva, Arindam Gupta and Nilesh Kumar

    Case Title :  Securitas AB v. The Regional Director, Ministry of Corporate Affairs and OrsCase Number :  WP(C) No. 12811 of 2022CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (DEL) 1270
    Next Story