RBI's 2017 Fraud Compensation Circular Applies Retrospectively, Covers Private Banks: Madras High Court

  • RBIs 2017 Fraud Compensation Circular Applies Retrospectively, Covers Private Banks: Madras High Court

    The Madras High Court has held that the RBI's July 6, 2017, fraud compensation circular applies retrospectively and that RBI's directions extend to private sector banks as well, rejecting Axis Bank's objections to their applicability.

    The court reasoned that the RBI Notification applied equally to all banks, as they deal with deposits made by customers whose interests are safeguarded by the RBI.

    Justice N. Anand Venkatesh therefore dismissed the Bank's review application challenging the High Court's earlier direction to recredit ₹16.15 lakh allegedly siphoned from Dadha Pharma LLP's account, holding that there was no error apparent on the face of the record warranting review.

    “In so far as the first ground that was urged on the side of the applicant bank is concerned, the same is liable to be rejected for the simple reason that the RBI Notification will equally apply to all the banks since they are dealing with the deposits made by depositors, whose interest is safeguarded by the RBI. Hence, the first ground is rejected.”, the Court observed.

    The writ petition was filed by Dadha Pharma LLP seeking a direction to Axis Bank to re credit ₹16.15 lakh allegedly siphoned from its current account. Despite being served notice in the writ petition, the bank did not appear or contest the matter.

    On June 12, 2025, the Court directed the bank to restore the amount within four weeks. Axis Bank subsequently filed the review application with a delay of 272 days. During the pendency of contempt proceedings, the bank deposited the amount, following which the contempt petition was closed on April 10, 2026.

    Rejecting the bank's contention that it was not given an opportunity to contest the writ petition, the Court observed that notice had been duly served and the bank had chosen not to appear. It held that the bank could not subsequently claim that it had been denied an opportunity to defend itself.

    The Court then examined the bank's contention that the alleged siphoning took place in 2011, when the RBI Notification dated April 8, 2002 was in force.

    Under the compensation policy framed pursuant to that notification, the bank's liability was capped at ₹25,000. The Court noted that the RBI's subsequent circular dated July 6, 2017, withdrew the earlier circular and removed the restriction that limited compensation to ₹25,000 irrespective of the amount siphoned from a depositor's account.

    "The circular of the year 2002 had fixed an upper cap and accordingly, the applicant bank issued a compensation policy restricting the upper limit of Rs.25,000/-. Subsequently, the RBI issued the circular of the year 2017 withdrawing the earlier circular. This circular rectified the patent error in the earlier circular, which restricted the total amount payable by the applicant bank at Rs.25,000/- irrespective of the amount that has been siphoned from the accounts of the depositors."

    The Court observed that the 2017 circular was beneficial in nature and had been issued to protect customers who lost their hard-earned money through fraudulent siphoning of funds. It held that such a beneficial circular ought to be given retrospective effect to ensure uniform and fair treatment of affected customers.

    Accordingly, the Court found no error apparent on the face of the record warranting review of its earlier order.

    For the Applicant: Advocate Rahul Balaji,

    For Respondent No. 1: D. Ferdinand, for BFS Legal

    Case Title :  Axis Bank Limited vs M/s.Dadha Pharma LLPCase Number :  Review A pplication No. 141 of 2026 & WMP.No.33298 of 2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (MAD) 366
    Next Story