Commercial Disputes Can Be Referred To Mediation Before Summons Is Issued: Delhi High Court

  • Commercial Disputes Can Be Referred To Mediation Before Summons Is Issued: Delhi High Court

    The Delhi High Court has held that a commercial dispute can be referred to mediation even before summons are issued. It has also clarified that courts can direct parties to maintain the status quo to ensure that mediation is not rendered futile.

    “Mediation can be resorted to at any stage, prior to or after the institution of the suit. There is no embargo to referring the dispute to mediation before issuing summons in the suit. The interim status quo that has been granted was merely a stepping aid of facilitating mediation, so that the mediation would not be rendered an empty exercise in futility,” a Division Bench of Justices C. Hari Shankar and Nivedita Anil Sharma observed.

    The court made the observation while dismissing an appeal by Visa Worldwide Pte Limited against an interim order referring its dispute with PayU Payments Private Limited and certain banks to the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) for mediation.

    The dispute concerns interchange reimbursement fee (IRF) claims arising from alleged misclassification of merchants under Merchant Category Codes (MCCs). ICICI Bank had raised claims before Visa, alleging that incorrect MCCs had been assigned to certain merchants.

    PayU contended that it did not assign these codes. It collected and verified merchant information before forwarding it to acquiring banks, which independently assessed the merchants' businesses and assigned the MCCs.

    PayU challenged Visa's IRF Compliance Process, alleging that it did not follow the dispute resolution mechanism under the Payment and Settlement Systems Act, 2007. It apprehended that the resulting claims could lead to deductions from its escrow account.

    PayU submitted that Yes Bank had deducted amounts towards IRF liability and subsequently reversed more than ₹5.95 crore. However, the bank continued to retain ₹6.88 crore. ICICI Bank had also raised claims before Visa of approximately ₹5.26 crore against Axis Bank, ₹27.3 crore against Airtel Payments Bank and ₹8.82 crore against IndusInd Bank. PayU apprehended that these banks could also recover the amounts from it through deductions from its escrow account.

    The single judge had asked the RBI to help the parties resolve the dispute within 30 days.

    The RBI was asked only to facilitate a settlement, not decide the claims. The single judge also restrained further IRF determinations and deductions relating to past transactions during mediation. Visa challenged this, arguing that PayU should have first attempted pre-institution mediation.

    The bench rejected the objection, finding PayU's concern over possible civil and criminal liability sufficient to justify urgent interim protection.

    The Bench clarified that a separate application seeking exemption from pre-institution mediation was not necessary. The plaintiff must plead and seek urgent interim relief in the plaint. The court must then satisfy itself that a plausible basis for seeking such relief exists and that the plea is not a camouflage to avoid Section 12A.

    The bench also rejected Visa's objection to the RBI's involvement. It clarified that the RBI had not been asked to adjudicate the dispute under the Payment and Settlement Systems Act. It was only facilitating mediation.

    Commending the single judge's approach, the court observed that resolving a commercial dispute through mediation could avoid expensive and acrimonious litigation.

    “The course of action adopted by the learned Single Judge is, in fact, eminently wholesome. Litigation, especially commercial litigation, tends to be red in tooth and claw. Acrimony abounds,” it observed.

    The court found no reason to interfere with the interim directions and dismissed Visa's appeal, with no order as to costs.

    For Appellant: Senior Advocate Akhil Sibal, along with Binsy Susan, Akshay Sharma, Pavitra Singh, Palak Kaushal, Ayushi Jain, Krishnesh Bapat and Mridul Tiwari

    For Respondent No. 1 (PayU): Senior Advocates Sandeep Sethi and Rajeeve Mehra, along with V. Anush Raajan, Ayush Singh Dhami, Meghna Tandon, Palak Bhargava, Shreya Sethi, Krisna Gambhir and Ritwik Sarma

    For Respondent No. 2 (Yes Bank): Karthik Somasundaram, Sonam Gupta, Mathew Chacko, Ankita Hariramani, Anandita Rajesh, Saumay Kapoor, Shiva Pande and Ritvika Poswal.

    For Respondent No. 3 (ICICI Bank): Varuna Bharale, Vivek Krishnani and Tanya Hasija

    For Respondent No. 5 (Airtel Payments Bank): Sidhant Kumar and Lahar Jain

    For Respondent No. 6 (IndusInd Bank): Neelam Rathore and Umang Saini

    Case Title :  VISA WORLDWIDE PTE LIMITED vs PAYU PAYMENTS PRIVATE LIMITED AND ORSCase Number :  FAO(OS) (COMM) 259/2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (DEL) 1246
    Next Story