Bank's Board Cannot Grant PC Act Prosecution Sanction; Only RBI Is Competent Authority: Bombay High Court

  • Banks Board Cannot Grant PC Act Prosecution Sanction; Only RBI Is Competent Authority: Bombay High Court

    The Bombay High Court has held that the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, overrides contrary provisions of the Companies Act and a banking company's Articles of Association in matters concerning the appointment and removal of its officers while quashing the prosecution sanction granted against former ICICI Bank MD and CEO Chanda Kochhar in the Videocon loan case.

    Justice Milind N. Jadhav held that the power to remove Kochhar from her position was vested with the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), making it the competent authority to grant sanction for her prosecution under the Prevention of Corruption Act.

    Rejecting the CBI's argument that the Board of Directors could grant sanction under the Companies Act and ICICI Bank's Articles of Association, the court ruled,

    “Moreover as discussed above, since provisions of BR Act clearly override those of the Companies Act, the Board of Directors is not / cannot be possessed of jurisdiction to grant sanction under Section 19 of PC Act. Therefore, Respondent No.1 cannot pounce on the statement / averment of Petitioner in paragraph No.1 of the Petition without reading the same in context with the grounds in the Petition.”

    The court noted that Section 19(1)(c) of the Prevention of Corruption Act requires sanction to prosecute a public servant from the authority competent to remove that person from office. It examined Sections 5-A, 35-B, 36-AA and 36-AC of the Banking Regulation Act and held that the statutory provisions placed the relevant power of removal with the RBI.

    In this regard, the Court observed, “Thus the power of removal vests with RBI and RBI only.”

    The court rejected the CBI's reliance on the bank's Articles of Association and the Companies Act to contend that the Board was competent to grant sanction. It held that the overriding provisions of the Banking Regulation Act could not be bypassed by relying on the Board's powers under the Companies Act or the bank's Articles of Association.

    The court also took note of ICICI Bank's recorded position concerning the two Videocon loans sanctioned by committees of which Kochhar was a member. It noted that the bank's position was that its rules and policies had not been contravened in the disbursement of the loans and that no wrongful loss had been caused to it.

    The Court observed, “Once the CBI itself records the alleged Competent Authority's submissions that the rules and policies of the bank were not contravened whatsoever in disbursement of the 2 loan amounts to Videocon Group of Industries by the Committee of which Petitioner was one of the Members and that no wrongful loss whatsoever was caused to the bank, then the impugned sanction order by the Board of Directors is even otherwise unsustainable in law.”

    The court further found that the Board had not been provided with the entire material collected during the investigation. It noted that only the CBI's letter seeking sanction and its report were circulated to the Board, while the supporting investigation material was not placed before it for consideration.

    The court also observed that the sanction order did not discuss witness statements, exhibits or documents pointing to Kochhar's alleged involvement in the offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act. It held that the sanction had been granted mechanically, without demonstrating application of mind or recording reasons.

    Holding that the sanction had been granted by an authority lacking jurisdiction and that the Board had failed to apply its mind to the material, the Court declared it illegal and a nullity.

    The court accordingly quashed the sanction order dated May 15, 2023, and the consequential actions taken by the Special Court for CBI at Greater Bombay. It also declined the CBI's request to stay the judgment for eight weeks.

    For Petitioner: Senior Advocate Abad Ponda, Advocates Rohan Dakshini, Pooja Kothari, Nimit Bhimjiyani, Aditya Upadhyay and Parth Khubalkar, i/b Rashmikant and Partners

    For CBI: Senior Advocate Anil Singh, Advocates Kuldeep Patil, Adarsh Vyas, Digvijay S. Kachare, Krishnakant Deshmukh, Sumitkumar Nimbalkar, Anay Joshi, Saili Dhuru, Saniki Joshi and Yukta Sawant, along with Limosine (DLA, CBI)

    For State: APP Rajeshree V. Newton

    Case Title :  Chanda Kochhar Versus Central Bureau of Investigation and Anr.Case Number :  WRIT PETITION NO.6636 OF 2024CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (BOM) 652
    Next Story