Arbitration Pleas Cannot Become Mini-Trials Through Routine Cross-Examination: Rajasthan High Court
Shivani PS
21 Nov 2026 2:59 PM IST

The Rajasthan High Court on 4 November held that questioning the source of statements in an affidavit or disputing their accuracy does not, by itself, warrant cross-examination in proceedings seeking interim protection under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
Justice Anand Sharma allowed a writ petition filed by Sita Devi challenging a Commercial Court order permitting the opposing parties to cross-examine her power-of-attorney holder, who had filed the Section 9 application and sworn the supporting affidavit on her behalf. The Bench said:
“If every objection regarding the source of knowledge of the person verifying an application, or every dispute concerning the correctness of the assertions made therein, is permitted to result in cross-examination, the proceedings may become protracted and lose their very purpose. Such a course would effectively convert an application for interim protection into a mini-trial, which is neither contemplated by Section 9 nor consistent with its object.”
Sita Devi had sought interim protection concerning the affairs and assets of ACV Explosives LLP under Section 9. Her general power-of-attorney holder, Rajendra Choudhary, filed the application and swore the supporting affidavit on her behalf.
ACV Explosives and the two other parties named in the petition, Hirendra Singh Choudhary and Charan Singh Choudhary, both sons of Ramnarayan Choudhary, sought to cross-examine Rajendra. They questioned his knowledge of the facts stated in the affidavit and the circumstances in which Sita Devi had authorised him to act.
On 10 September 2026, Commercial Court No. 1, Jaipur Metropolitan-II, allowed their application under Order XIX Rule 2 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
Sita Devi challenged the order before the High Court, arguing that the Commercial Court could decide her request for interim protection on the basis of the pleadings and documents on record. She contended that the opposing parties had demonstrated no exceptional circumstances warranting cross-examination.
ACV Explosives and the other parties argued that the affidavit referred to events that had occurred well before the execution of the power of attorney and that Rajendra had not established personal knowledge of those events.
They also relied on Rule 4(1) of the Rajasthan Arbitration Rules, 2003, which prescribes the conditions under which an authorised person may sign and verify an application and swear an affidavit on behalf of an applicant.
The Court observed that although the Commercial Court had the power to order cross-examination, it had to determine whether the material available before it justified interim protection of the subject matter of the arbitration.
It said that the Commercial Court could consider doubts about Rajendra's personal knowledge while assessing the evidentiary value of his affidavit. However, such doubts did not automatically necessitate cross-examination. It added:
“In the present case, the principal objection of the respondents is that the attorney holder may not possess personal knowledge of all the events referred to in the affidavit. Such an objection may certainly be considered by the Commercial Court while assessing the evidentiary worth of the affidavit. However, the mere existence of such an objection does not, by itself, necessitate cross-examination.”
Further, the Bench added that the Commercial Court could independently examine whether the requirements of Rule 4(1) had been satisfied.
Finding that the 10 September order did not adequately explain why cross-examination was necessary, it quashed the order and dismissed the application seeking Rajendra's cross-examination.
Accordingly, the High Court directed the Commercial Court to decide Sita Devi's interim application preferably within four weeks of receiving a certified copy of the judgment, without being influenced by its observations on cross-examination.
Appearances for petitioner (Sita Devi): Advocates S.S. Hora, Himanshu Agarwal.
Appearances for respondent (ACV Explosives LLP, Hirendra Singh Choudhary and Charan Singh Choudhary): Advocate Aditya Jain.
