Bombay High Court Allows Chembur Society Redevelopment, Says Homebuyers Can Sue Former Developer

  • Bombay High Court Allows Chembur Society Redevelopment, Says Homebuyers Can Sue Former Developer

    The Bombay High Court on 18 November upheld an order lifting the freeze on redevelopment of Chembur Shivmurti Cooperative Housing Society in Mumbai, allowing the society and its new developer, Adityaraj Housing Corporation, to proceed with the project despite claims by homebuyers who had booked flats with the former developer.

    Justice N. J. Jamadar dismissed six appeals filed by the homebuyers and an Association of Allottees, holding that buyers who had no contractual relationship with the society could pursue their claims against the former developer. The Bench said:

    “Since the appellants can workout their remedies against the erstwhile developer, the Appellate Tribunal was fully justified in interfering with the wholly unsustainable order passed by the Authority…”

    The 36-member society had appointed G. A. Builders Pvt. Ltd. on 25 October 2007 to redevelop its dilapidated building in Subhash Nagar. Although the members vacated their homes, the developer stopped paying transit rent and abandoned the project after completing only part of the construction.

    The society terminated the redevelopment agreement on 8 August 2019 and appointed Adityaraj Housing Corporation as the new developer. The validity of the termination, however, remained pending before an arbitral tribunal.

    Meanwhile, several homebuyers claimed that they had paid G. A. Builders for flats in the portion of the project earmarked for open-market sale. They approached the Maharashtra real estate regulator seeking possession of the flats and membership in the society.

    On 31 July 2025, the regulator placed the project's registration on hold, restrained Adityaraj from advertising or entering into transactions for the project, and directed the parties to maintain status quo until the conclusion of the arbitration and other proceedings.

    The society and Adityaraj challenged the order before the appellate tribunal. On 6 January 2026, the tribunal set aside the restrictions, holding that the buyers could not enforce their agreements with G. A. Builders against the society or its new developer.

    The homebuyers and the Association of Allottees then approached the High Court through six second appeals challenging the removal of the redevelopment freeze.

    Before the High Court, the buyers argued that the appellate tribunal had overlooked the protections available under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. They relied on Section 15, which prescribes regulatory approval and the consent of two-thirds of the allottees for specified transfers by a promoter, and Section 18, which provides remedies for defaults by promoters.

    The society and Adityaraj relied on an earlier High Court ruling dated 12 October 2023, which had rejected claims by buyers who had entered into agreements with G. A. Builders against the society.

    The Court reiterated that the buyers' agreements with G. A. Builders did not create any enforceable rights against the society or its assets, including the flats earmarked for open-market sale. Since the society was not a party to those agreements, the buyers could pursue their contractual remedies only against the former developer. It said:

    “The absence of privity of contract between the third party purchasers and the society is the rationale for not upholding the claim of such third party purchasers, to enforce their rights against the society,”

    The buyers also relied on a consumer case in which another housing society had taken possession of flats already allotted by its former developer and reassigned them to its own members. The Bench distinguished that decision on its facts.

    It noted that the Supreme Court had dismissed the appeals against that ruling without recording reasons. The dismissal, therefore, did not displace the High Court's earlier rulings on claims by buyers who had contracted only with a former developer.

    Justice Jamadar further observed that continuing the freeze would leave the society's members waiting for the outcome of arbitration and other proceedings, despite having vacated their homes nearly 15 years earlier.

    Describing the members as having been “left in the lurch for almost 15 years”, he held that the appellate tribunal had rightly lifted the restrictions on redevelopment.

    Accordingly, the High Court dismissed all six appeals, disposed of the pending interim applications and made no order as to costs, finding no substantial question of law.

    Appearances for petitioners (flat buyers and Association of Allottees): Advocates Dr. Sanjay Chaturvedi, Sarosh Bharucha, Shreeram and Mehdarin Bhatt.

    Appearances for respondents (Chembur Shivmurti Cooperative Housing Society, Adityaraj Housing Corporation, G. A. Builders Pvt. Ltd. and Association of Allottees): Advocates Mohanish Chaudhari, Dipashri Raorane, Sarosh Bharucha, Shreeram and Mehdarin Bhatt.

    Case Title :  Ashwin Jain and Bhavana Jain v. Chembur Shivmurti Cooperative Housing Society & Ors., with connected appealsCase Number :  Second Appeal Nos. 302, 313, 304, 286 and 287 of 2026 and Second Appeal (St.) No. 10515 of 2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (BOM) 653
    Next Story