Amicable Consultation With Company Chairman Does Not Constitute Arbitration Agreement: Delhi High Court
Shivani PS
20 Nov 2026 2:03 PM IST

The Delhi High Court on 19 November held that a clause requiring disputes to be resolved amicably in consultation with a company's chairman does not constitute an arbitration agreement, even if it is titled “arbitration” and makes the chairman's decision “final and binding”.
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma dismissed Janvee Contracts Pvt. Ltd.'s petition seeking appointment of an arbitrator against Ahluwalia Contracts (India) Ltd. in a Rs. 19.30 lakh payment dispute arising from construction work at a medical college in Himachal Pradesh. The Bench observed:
“Though the decision of the Chairman is stated to be 'final and binding', such finality cannot, by itself, convert a non-arbitral dispute resolution mechanism into an arbitration agreement. The nature of the process contemplated by the clause has to be considered, and the process here is one of amicable resolution and consultation, rather than adjudication...”
Ahluwalia issued Janvee a Rs. 1.99 crore work order on 1 May 2021 to mix, transport and pump concrete at the Dr. Radha Krishnan Medical College and Hospital project in Hamirpur. Janvee claimed Rs. 13.86 lakh in outstanding dues and withheld security became payable on 20 December 2022. It sought Rs. 19.30 lakh, including interest at 15% per annum. Ahluwalia's chairman informed Janvee on 21 March 2024 that the company's records showed no outstanding dues.
Clause 18 of Annexure III to the work order stated:
“In case of any difference or dispute between the parties which may arise on context of this contrat and its performance, the same will be resolved amicably in consultation with Chairman-ACIL and his decision shall be final and binding on both the parties.”
Janvee invoked the clause through a notice dated 28 July 2025 under Section 21 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Ahluwalia denied the claim and disputed the existence of an arbitration agreement on 23 August 2025.
Subsequently, Janvee approached the High Court under Section 11(6) of the Act seeking appointment of a sole arbitrator. It relied on the clause's heading and the chairman's decision being final and binding, and sought an independent arbitrator on the ground that Ahluwalia's chairman headed the company.
Ahluwalia contended that Clause 18 provided only for consultation and amicable settlement. It also relied on Clause 19, which conferred exclusive jurisdiction on Delhi courts.
The Court said an arbitration agreement need not use any prescribed wording. However, the contract, read as a whole, must show that the parties intended to submit disputes to a private forum for adjudication and to be bound by its decision after having an opportunity to present their respective cases. It said:
“Conversely, the mere use of the word 'arbitration' does not make a clause an arbitration agreement, if its substance does not reflect such an intention...”
Further, the Bench noted that Clause 18 provided for consultation with Ahluwalia's chairman but did not contemplate the submission of claims and defences for adjudication. It required amicable settlement through consultation rather than referring disputes to the chairman for a ruling. It stated:
“The expression 'resolved amicably' denotes a resolution arrived at in a friendly manner, by mutual accord between the parties. Similarly, the expression 'in consultation with' connotes a process of deliberation and exchange of views, and not a process of adjudication…”
Justice Sharma also noted that the heading also covered Clause 19, which conferred exclusive jurisdiction on Delhi courts. It treated the heading as a “general caption” and held that the operative language of Clause 18 did not establish the parties' intention to arbitrate.
Accordingly, the High Court dismissed the petition, leaving Janvee free to pursue other remedies available in law, without adjudicating whether Ahluwalia owed the claimed amount.
Appearances for petitioner (Janvee Contracts Pvt Ltd): Advocates Gaurav Kumar Singh.
Appearances for respondent (Ahluwalia Contracts (India) Ltd.): Advocates Sunil Mund, Mritunjay Singh, Jagjeet Singh, Vedant Mund.
