Arbitral Award Cannot Be Reduced Merely Because Government Entity Has To Pay: Supreme Court

  • Arbitral Award Cannot Be Reduced Merely Because Government Entity Has To Pay: Supreme Court

    The Supreme Court has held that an arbitral award cannot be reduced merely because the entity liable to pay it is a government body, observing that an award backed by valid evidence cannot be interfered with simply because the amount appears excessive.

    A bench of Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran made the observation while restoring an arbitral award in favour of Marino Dredgeco Limited for additional dredging work at Kolkata Port Trust's Sagar Island pilot station.

    Relying on the apex court's ruling in Pam Developments Private Ltd. v. State of West Bengal, the top court held,

    “There can hence be no interference caused to the quantum of claim decided by the Arbitrator, based on valid material, merely for the reason that the award debtor is a Government entity and that the quantum appears to be excessive without any substantiation for such a ground being raised against the award itself,” the court observed.

    The dispute arose from a contract awarded to Marino for dredging the riverbed and shores at Sagar Island to create an approach channel and basin for a shore-based pilot station.

    The work was to be completed within 18 months, but adverse force majeure conditions, which were not attributable to Marino, caused delays. Marino also contended that the actual soil conditions differed from the data supplied by the Port Trust and that the failure to construct protective walls led to further siltation, requiring repeated dredging.

    On July 19, 2000, the Port Trust wrote to Marino assigning additional dredging work. The pilot station was inaugurated by the Port Trust chairman on April 17, 2001, using the channel dredged by Marino.

    The Port Trust paid ₹2.79 crore out of the ₹2.86 crore due under the original contract. The subsequent arbitration concerned payment for the additional work. On November 3, 2003, the arbitrator ruled in Marino's favour.

    The Port Trust challenged the award under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. A single judge of the Calcutta High Court upheld it. However, a Division Bench hearing the Port Trust's appeal under Section 37 halved the award and reduced interest to 6% on the principal amount from February 8, 2002.

    Although the Division Bench accepted that the award was supported by evidence, it held that the additional work exceeding 70% of the original contract value shocked its conscience.

    Both parties approached the Supreme Court. Marino argued that the High Court had focused on the size of the bills without examining why the additional dredging was necessary. The Port Trust denied assigning the additional work and relied on the absence of a completion certificate. It sought to have the entire award set aside or, alternatively, retain the High Court's reduction.

    The top court found that the Port Trust's letter dated July 19, 2000 established that additional dredging had been entrusted to Marino to keep the channel and basin operational.

    It noted that the arbitrator had quantified the work based on measurements and invoices, including joint measurements of the additional work. The High Court itself had accepted that the absence of a completion certificate could not defeat Marino's claim for payment for work actually carried out.

    The court further held that the High Court could not invoke the 'shocking the conscience' test merely because the additional work exceeded 70% of the original contract value. The limited jurisdiction under Section 37 did not permit the High Court to re-examine the merits of an award supported by adequate evidence.

    The court allowed Marino's appeal, set aside the High Court's ruling, and restored the arbitral award. The Port Trust's appeal was consequently disposed of.

    For Appellant (Marino Dredgeco Limited): Senior Advocates R. Anand Padmanabhan and Amitava Mukherjee.

    For Respondent (The Board of Trustees of the Port of Kolkata): Senior Advocate Siddharth Bhatnagar.

    Case Title :  M/s Marino Dredgeco Limited v. The Board of Trustees of the Port of Kolkata, with connected appealCase Number :  Civil Appeal Nos. 14303 and 14304 of 2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz SC 356
    Next Story